SCARS Institute Community Portal

ScamsNOW!

The SCARS Institute Magazine about Scam Victims-Survivors, Scams, Fraud & Cybercrime

SCARS Institute - 12 Years of Service to Scam Victims & Survivors - 2025/2026
The Sublime Experience of Betrayal - An Essay - 2025

The Sublime Experience of Betrayal – An Essay

The Sublime in the Deception and Betrayal of the Scam Victim’s Experience

Primary Category: Editorial & Commentary  /  Scam Victim Recovery Philosophy

Author:
•  Tim McGuinness, Ph.D., DFin, MCPO, MAnth – Anthropologist, Scientist, Polymath, Director of the Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.
Author Biographies Below

About This Article

The concept of the sublime has captivated philosophers, artists, and thinkers for centuries, evoking a sense of awe, wonder, and transcendence that defies easy definition. At its core, the sublime refers to something that is so vast, powerful, or profound that it overwhelms the senses and challenges our understanding of the world. It is an experience that lifts us beyond the mundane, transporting us to a realm where the boundaries of human perception and comprehension are pushed to their limits.

Note: This article is intended for informational purposes and does not replace professional medical advice. If you are experiencing distress, please consult a qualified mental health professional.

The Sublime Experience of Betrayal - An Essay - 2025

The Sublime in the Deception and Betrayal of the Scam Victim’s Experience – An Essay

Author’s Note

In this essay, my goal is to explore the ‘Sublime,’ a different aspect of the scam victim’s experience. A word that most victims would never have applied to the experience of being scammed, the betrayal, and the trauma that followed. That is because most people do not understand what that word means.

Prof. Tim McGuinness, Ph.D.

The True Meaning of Sublime: An Exploration of Awe and Transcendence

The concept of the sublime has captivated philosophers, artists, and thinkers for centuries, evoking a sense of awe, wonder, and transcendence that defies easy definition. At its core, the sublime refers to something that is so vast, powerful, or profound that it overwhelms the senses and challenges our understanding of the world. It is an experience that lifts us beyond the mundane, transporting us to a realm where the boundaries of human perception and comprehension are pushed to their limits.

The word “sublime” originates from the Latin word “sublimis,” which means “elevated” or “lofty.” This root word has been used in various contexts to describe something that is above or beyond the ordinary.

Historical Perspectives on the Sublime

The exploration of the sublime has its roots in ancient philosophy, with early discussions found in the works of Longinus, who, in his treatise “On the Sublime” (circa 1st century CE), explored the power of rhetoric to evoke a sense of grandeur and awe. However, it was in the 18th century that the concept gained significant traction, particularly through the works of Edmund Burke and Immanuel Kant.

Burke, in his “Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful” (1757), distinguished the sublime from the beautiful, arguing that the sublime was associated with feelings of terror and self-preservation, while the beautiful was linked to pleasure and desire. He saw the sublime as a powerful and often frightening experience that could evoke a sense of the infinite and the uncontrollable.

Kant, in his “Critique of Judgment” (1790), expanded on these ideas, defining the sublime as an experience that transcends the limits of human reason and imagination. For Kant, the sublime was not merely an aesthetic category but a philosophical one, representing the mind’s struggle to comprehend the infinite and the absolute. He identified two types of the sublime: the mathematical sublime, which deals with the vastness of space and time, and the dynamical sublime, which involves the power and might of nature.

The Sublime in Art and Nature

The sublime is often associated with grand and awe-inspiring scenes in nature, such as towering mountains, vast oceans, or stormy skies (such as the featured image for this article). These natural phenomena can evoke a sense of insignificance and wonder, reminding us of the immense scale and power of the universe. Artists throughout history have sought to capture the sublime in their work, using techniques and compositions that aim to convey the overwhelming and the infinite.

In literature, the sublime is often invoked through descriptions of vast, untamed landscapes or cosmic vistas. Poets like William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge explored the sublime in their works, using language and imagery to transport readers to a state of awe and contemplation. In the visual arts, painters like Caspar David Friedrich and J.M.W. Turner sought to depict the sublime through their landscapes, often featuring dramatic skies and rugged terrain that evoke a sense of the infinite and the untameable.

“Lines Written A Few Miles Above Tintern Abbey” by William Wordsworth

(Lines 79-86)

Left Open Quote - on ScamsNOW.com…The sounding cataract
Haunted me like a passion: the tall rock,
The mountain, and the deep and gloomy wood,
Their colours and their forms, were then to me
An appetite: a feeling and a love,
That had no need of a remoter charm,
By thought supplied, or any interest
Unborrowed from the eye.

The Sublime in Fiction

Unlike what you might have thought, the sublime is profoundly different than what most people think.

The writings of H.P. Lovecraft, Clive Barker, Whitley Strieber, and Dan Simmons are deeply intertwined with the concept of the sublime, each exploring different facets of the overwhelming, the transcendent, and the terrifying. Their works often delve into realms where the ordinary gives way to the extraordinary, evoking a sense of awe, wonder, and sometimes, profound horror. If you have never read their works, you would not understand, but suffice it to say that in their works the sublime can be glimpsed in the fullest form of its meaning.

H.P. Lovecraft

H.P. Lovecraft’s cosmic horror is perhaps the most direct and influential exploration of the sublime in literature. His works often center on the idea of the “cosmic sublime,” where the vastness and indifference of the universe are juxtaposed with the insignificance of human existence. In stories like “The Call of Cthulhu” and “At the Mountains of Madness,” Lovecraft presents ancient, otherworldly entities (also called ‘Eldritch Horrors’) and lost civilizations that dwarf human comprehension and achievement. The sublime in Lovecraft is not just about awe but also about the terrifying realization of our own insignificance in the face of the cosmic unknown. His prose often aims to evoke a sense of the infinite and the unknowable, pushing the boundaries of human perception and understanding.

Clive Barker

Clive Barker’s work, particularly his “Books of Blood” and novels like “The Hellbound Heart,” explores the sublime through a lens of the grotesque and body horror. Barker’s sublime is often found in the transformation and transgression of the human form, where the boundaries between the physical and the metaphysical are blurred. His characters often confront entities or experiences that are beyond their understanding, leading to a sense of the sublime that is both awe-inspiring and terrifying. Barker’s use of vivid, often visceral imagery serves to heighten the reader’s sense of the overwhelming and the transcendent, as characters are pushed to the limits of their endurance and sanity.

Whitley Strieber

Whitley Strieber’s works, such as “Communion” and “The Grays,” delve into the sublime through the exploration of alien encounters and the unknown. Streiber’s sublime is often rooted in the mystery and the unknowable, where human beings are confronted with entities and experiences that defy explanation. His prose aims to evoke a sense of the infinite and the otherworldly, as characters grapple with the implications of contact with beings from beyond our world. Strieber’s work often explores the psychological and emotional impact of such encounters, pushing the reader to contemplate the vastness of the universe and our place within it. Think for a moment, how similar that is to the experience of encountering a fake identity that seems to know every way imaginable to manipulate you?

Dan Simmons

Dan Simmons, known for his novel “The Terror,” explores the sublime through a historical and supernatural lens. Set against the backdrop of a doomed Arctic expedition, “The Terror” weaves together elements of horror, the supernatural, and the psychological. Simons’ sublime is often found in the vast, unforgiving landscape of the Arctic, where the characters are pitted against not only the elements but also an ancient, malevolent entity. The sublime in Simmons’ work is about the overwhelming power of nature and the unknown, as well as the psychological and emotional toll it takes on the characters. His prose often aims to evoke a sense of the infinite and the terrifying, as the characters are pushed to the brink of their endurance and sanity.

In his “Hyperion” series, Simmons further explores the sublime through the lens of cosmic horror and the vastness of space. The series is set in a future where humanity has colonized numerous planets, and the characters are confronted with ancient, incomprehensible entities and the overwhelming scale of the universe. The sublime in “Hyperion” is manifested in the awe-inspiring and terrifying beauty of the cosmos, where the characters grapple with the insignificance of human existence in the face of the infinite. Simmons uses the sublime to explore themes of destiny, free will, and the human struggle for meaning in a universe that is both beautiful and indifferent. The series often pushes the boundaries of human perception and understanding, inviting readers to contemplate the vast and unknowable nature of the cosmos and our place within it. Through the experiences of the characters, Simons evokes a sense of the sublime that is both transcendent and horrifying, challenging readers to confront the profound and often unsettling implications of the infinite.

Common Themes and the Sublime

Across these authors, several common themes emerge that relate to the concept of the sublime:

  1. The Infinite and the Unknowable: All four authors explore the idea of the infinite and the unknowable, whether it’s the vastness of the cosmos in Lovecraft, the grotesque transformations in Barker, the alien encounters in Strieber, or the supernatural horror in Simmons. This exploration often leads to a sense of awe and terror, as characters and readers are confronted with something beyond their comprehension.
  2. The Power of Nature and the Supernatural: Nature and the supernatural often serve as catalysts for the sublime in these works. Whether it’s the harsh, unforgiving landscape of the Arctic in Simmons or the otherworldly entities in Lovecraft, the power of these forces is used to evoke a sense of the overwhelming and the transcendent.
  3. Psychological and Emotional Impact: These authors often focus on the psychological and emotional impact of confronting the sublime. Characters are pushed to their limits, experiencing a range of emotions from awe and wonder to terror and despair. This exploration of the human psyche adds depth to the concept of the sublime, highlighting its transformative and often traumatic effects.
  4. Transcendence and Transformation: The sublime in these works often involves a sense of transcendence or transformation, where characters are changed by their encounters with the overwhelming and the unknown. This transformation can be physical, as in Barker’s work, or psychological, as in the others, but it always involves a profound and often irreversible change.

In conclusion, the writings of Lovecraft, Barker, Strieber, and Simmons offer rich and varied explorations of the sublime, each contributing unique perspectives and themes to our understanding of the overwhelming, the transcendent, and the terrifying. Their works invite readers to contemplate the vastness and mystery of the universe, the power of the unknown, and the depths of the human psyche, all of which are central to the concept of the sublime.

The Sublime in Modern Contexts

In contemporary discussions, the concept of the sublime has been expanded to include a range of experiences and phenomena that challenge our understanding and evoke a sense of transcendence. This can include technological marvels, such as the launch of a rocket or the vastness of the digital universe, as well as profound emotional or spiritual experiences that push the boundaries of human perception.

The sublime can also be found in the realm of the abstract, where mathematical concepts or scientific theories that grapple with the nature of reality and existence can evoke a sense of awe and wonder. The theories of relativity, quantum mechanics, and cosmology, for instance, deal with concepts that are so vast and complex that they challenge our everyday understanding of the world, inviting us to contemplate the infinite and the unknown.

Confronting the Sublime: An Encounter

Coming face to face with the sublime is an experience that can be as transformative as it is unsettling, a moment where the boundaries of ordinary perception are shattered, and one is thrust into a realm of the extraordinary. This encounter can occur in various forms, through the awe-inspiring grandeur of nature, the profound impact of art, the terrifying depths of cosmic horror, or the unsettling mysteries of the supernatural. Regardless of its source, the sublime demands a response, challenging individuals to confront the vast and unknowable, and in doing so, to question the very foundations of their existence and understanding.

The Initial Impact: Overwhelmed and Transfixed

The first encounter with the sublime is often marked by a sense of being overwhelmed, where the individual is transfixed by the sheer magnitude or profundity of the experience. This can be a moment of pure awe, where the beauty or power of what is encountered leaves one speechless and humbled. In nature, this might be the sight of a vast canyon or the majesty of a storm at sea; in art, it could be a painting that captures the essence of human emotion or a symphony that resonates with the depths of the soul. The sublime, in these instances, is not just about the external stimulus but about the internal response it evokes, a sense of being connected to something greater than oneself, yet also profoundly alone in the face of its immensity.

The Psychological Journey: From Awe to Dissonance

As the initial shock of the sublime experience subsides, individuals often find themselves on a psychological journey that can lead to cognitive dissonance. This dissonance arises from the conflict between the overwhelming nature of the experience and one’s existing beliefs and perceptions. For example, a person who has always held a rational, scientific worldview might find their foundations shaken by an encounter with the supernatural or the cosmic. The sublime, in these cases, challenges the individual to reconcile the irrational or inexplicable with their rational understanding, leading to a period of internal struggle and reflection.

Integration and Transformation: Resolving the Dissonance

The process of integrating the sublime experience into one’s worldview can be a catalyst for personal transformation. As individuals work to resolve the cognitive dissonance, they often emerge with a new understanding of themselves and the world around them. This transformation can involve a shift in beliefs, a deepening of empathy, or a newfound appreciation for the mysteries of existence. In some cases, the encounter with the sublime can lead to a spiritual or philosophical awakening, where the individual feels a profound connection to the universe and their place within it.

The Sublime in Everyday Life: Finding the Extraordinary

While the sublime is often associated with grand or otherworldly experiences, it can also be found in the everyday, in moments of profound connection or insight. A simple act of kindness, a moment of shared laughter, or a sudden realization about one’s purpose can all evoke a sense of the sublime. These everyday encounters remind us that the extraordinary is not always distant or inaccessible but can be found in the ordinary, waiting to be recognized and cherished.

Coming face-to-face with the sublime is a journey of discovery and transformation, where the individual is pushed to the limits of their perception and understanding. It is a confrontation with the vast and unknowable that can lead to a profound sense of awe, terror, and ultimately, a deeper understanding of oneself and the world. Whether through the grandeur of nature, the depth of art, or the mysteries of the cosmos, the sublime invites us to transcend the ordinary and embrace the extraordinary, offering a glimpse into the depths of human consciousness and the potential for transformation that lies within each of us. In this way, the sublime is not just an experience to be witnessed but a call to engage with the profound and the mysterious, to question, to feel, and to grow in the face of the overwhelming and the unknown.

The Personal Sublime

Beyond the grand and the cosmic, the sublime can also be found in deeply personal experiences that transcend the ordinary. These experiences can range from moments of profound emotional connection and spiritual enlightenment to the intense and often terrifying realms of horror and fear. For scam victims, the journey through betrayal and trauma can lead to a personal sublime that is as awe-inspiring as it is terrifying, pushing the boundaries of their emotional and psychological endurance.

The Sublime in Horror and Fear

The experience of horror and fear can be a powerful gateway to the sublime, where the intensity of emotion transcends the ordinary and touches upon the extraordinary. For scam victims, the initial shock of discovery, realizing that they have been deceived and manipulated, can evoke a sense of horror that is both overwhelming and profound. This horror is not just a reaction to the loss but a confrontation with the vast and unknowable nature of human deceit. It is a moment where the victim is forced to grapple with the reality that their trust has been betrayed, and their perception of the world has been fundamentally altered.

Fear, too, plays a crucial role in this personal sublime. The fear of the unknown, the fear of vulnerability, and the fear of further betrayal can all contribute to an experience that is both terrifying and transcendent. This fear can push the victim to the edge of their emotional limits, where they must confront not only the external threat of the scammer but also the internal struggles of self-doubt and insecurity. In this state, the victim may experience a sense of awe at the power of their own emotions and the depth of their psychological resilience.

The Transcendent Nature of Trauma

The trauma experienced by scam victims can be seen as a form of the sublime, where the overwhelming nature of the experience pushes the victim beyond their usual boundaries of comprehension and emotion. This transcendence is not a pleasant or comfortable experience; it is a journey through the darkest aspects of the human condition, where the victim must confront their deepest fears and insecurities. Yet, within this darkness, there is a potential for growth and transformation that is uniquely sublime.

For some victims, this journey can lead to a profound sense of self-discovery and empowerment. As they navigate the complexities of their trauma, they may uncover strengths and resources within themselves that they never knew existed. This discovery can be a moment of sublime realization, where the victim transcends their initial state of horror and fear to emerge with a deeper understanding of their own resilience and capacity for healing. It is a personal sublime that is born from the ashes of betrayal, offering a glimpse into the potential for human transformation and growth.

The Sublime in Emotional Connection and Healing

While the sublime in horror and fear is a powerful and often overwhelming experience, it is also possible to find the sublime in the moments of emotional connection and healing that follow. As scam victims seek support and understanding from others, they may experience a profound sense of connection that transcends the boundaries of self and other. This connection can be a source of comfort and strength, reminding the victim that they are not alone in their journey and that there is a community of support and empathy available to them.

Additionally, the process of healing itself can be a sublime experience, where the victim engages in a deep and transformative journey of self-reflection and growth. Through therapy, support groups, or personal reflection, the victim may uncover layers of emotion and understanding that were previously hidden. This journey can lead to a sense of spiritual or emotional enlightenment, where the victim emerges with a renewed sense of purpose and a deeper appreciation for the complexities of human experience.

The personal sublime, as experienced by scam victims, is a complex and often paradoxical journey that encompasses both the terrifying and the transcendent. It is a realm where the overwhelming nature of horror and fear can lead to profound moments of self-discovery and growth. By embracing this personal sublime, victims can find a sense of awe and wonder in their own resilience and capacity for healing, transforming their trauma into a source of strength and understanding. In this way, the sublime, with all its power and mystery, offers a unique perspective on the human capacity to endure and transcend even the darkest of experiences, reminding us of the depth and complexity of human consciousness and the potential for transformation that lies within each of us.

The Sublime and the Trauma of Scam Victims

A Paradox of Betrayal and Awe

The experience of scam victims, marked by profound horror and betrayal, might seem worlds apart from the concept of the sublime, which is often associated with awe and transcendence. However, as I have said above, a deeper exploration reveals that the trauma of scam victims can be understood as a perverse form of the sublime, where the overwhelming nature of the experience pushes the victim beyond their usual boundaries of comprehension and emotion. This paradoxical relationship between the sublime and the trauma of scam victims offers a unique lens through which to understand the depth and complexity of their experience.

The Sublime as a Disruptive Force

In its classical definition, the sublime is a disruptive force that challenges our sense of order and control. It is an experience that overwhelms the senses and the mind, forcing us to confront the vastness and power of something beyond our immediate understanding. For scam victims, the betrayal and horror they experience can be seen as a similarly disruptive force, shattering their sense of trust, security, and self-worth. The scam, much like a natural disaster or a cosmic event, is an external force that imposes itself on their lives, rewriting their narratives and challenging their perceptions of reality.

The Betrayal of Trust: A Modern Form of the Sublime

Trust is a fundamental aspect of human relationships and societal interactions. It is the unseen scaffolding that supports our daily lives, allowing us to navigate the world with a sense of safety and predictability. For scam victims, the betrayal of trust is a profound and personal experience of the sublime, where the ordinary is suddenly transformed into the extraordinary. The scammer, often presenting as a charismatic and trustworthy figure, exploits this trust, using it as a tool to manipulate and deceive. The victim’s world, once stable and predictable, is suddenly upended, and they are forced to confront the reality that their faith in others has been misplaced. This experience of betrayal can evoke a sense of awe and horror, as the victim grapples with the overwhelming realization that their perception of the world has been fundamentally altered.

The Horror of Disillusionment

The horror experienced by scam victims is not just a reaction to the financial or emotional loss but also to the disillusionment that follows. It is a horror born of the sublime, where the victim is confronted with the vast and unknowable nature of human deception. This disillusionment can lead to a profound sense of existential dread, as the victim questions the very foundations of their beliefs and values. The scam, in this sense, acts as a catalyst for a personal crisis, pushing the victim to the edge of their emotional and psychological limits. It is an experience that transcends the ordinary, inviting the victim into a realm of uncertainty and doubt, where the lines between truth and falsehood, good and evil, become blurred.

The Paradox of Power and Vulnerability

The sublime often involves a paradox of power and vulnerability, where the individual is simultaneously overwhelmed and empowered by the experience. For scam victims, this paradox is evident in their journey from vulnerability to a newfound strength. Initially, the victim is in a state of profound vulnerability, exposed to the manipulations of the scammer and the harsh realities of their deception. However, as they process their trauma and seek justice or healing, they may discover an inner resilience and strength that they never knew existed. This transformation, from victim to survivor, is a sublime experience in itself, where the individual transcends their initial state of horror and betrayal to emerge with a deeper understanding of themselves and the world around them.

The Collective Sublime: Community Impact

The trauma of scam victims is not an isolated experience but one that ripples through communities, affecting families, friends, and even broader social networks. This collective impact can be seen as a form of the sublime, where the individual experience of betrayal and horror is amplified and reflected in the reactions and support of others. The community’s response to the victim’s plight, whether through empathy, support, or collective action against the scammer, can evoke a sense of awe and unity, as people come together to address a shared challenge. This collective sublime experience can provide a source of comfort and strength for the victim, reminding them that they are not alone in their journey and that their trauma has the power to inspire change and solidarity.

The relationship between the sublime and the trauma of scam victims is a complex and paradoxical one, where the overwhelming and disruptive nature of the scam experience pushes the victim beyond their usual boundaries of comprehension and emotion. It is a perverse form of the sublime, where the awe and transcendence are intertwined with horror and betrayal. By understanding this relationship, we can gain a deeper appreciation for the depth and complexity of the scam victim’s experience, recognizing it as a profound and transformative journey that, while painful, can also lead to growth, resilience, and a renewed sense of self and community. In this way, the sublime, with all its power and mystery, offers a unique perspective on the human capacity to endure and transcend even the darkest of experiences.

Conclusion

The true meaning of the sublime lies in its ability to evoke a sense of awe, wonder, and transcendence that pushes the limits of human perception and comprehension. It is an experience that reminds us of the vastness and complexity of the universe and the depth of human consciousness. Whether found in the grandeur of nature, the profundity of art, or the intimacy of personal experience, the sublime invites us to contemplate the infinite and the unknown, offering a glimpse into the mysteries that lie beyond the horizon of our understanding. In embracing the sublime, we open ourselves to a world of possibility and wonder, where the ordinary gives way to the extraordinary, and the finite meets the infinite.

 

 

The Sublime Experience of Betrayal - An Essay - 2025

Glossary

  • Aesthetic Awe — This term describes a sudden feeling of wonder triggered by something perceived as grand or profound. It widens attention and quiets rumination, which helps scam victims step back from shame and see events with more balance.
  • Affective Magnitude — This describes the sheer intensity of feeling that follows the discovery of deception. It helps readers recognize why emotions spike and why short, steady calming practices reduce overload.
  • Alien-Encounter Motif — This concept frames contact with the unknown as startling and disorienting. It helps readers recognize why meeting a deceptive persona can feel otherworldly and why grounding skills restore orientation.
  • Arctic Sublime — This phrase captures the overwhelming power of harsh environments used in storytelling to evoke fear and awe. It normalizes the shock response to betrayal by showing how vast, unforgiving contexts strain judgment.
  • Awe–Terror Duality — This names the mix of wonder and fear that can arise when reality feels larger than expected. It validates strong reactions and guides readers to pair curiosity with safety checks before acting.
  • Betrayal Sublime — This captures the shocking scale of harm when trust collapses. It reminds readers to separate the scammer’s skill at manipulation from personal worth and to rebuild safeguards step by step.
  • Body-Horror Sublime — This idea reflects fear and fascination with the altered body or identity. It explains why forged identities and deep emotional manipulation feel invasive and why somatic calming practices can help.
  • Boundary of Comprehension — This marks the point where events stop making sense. It signals time to pause, ground in facts, and ask a trusted outsider to review messages, money requests, or documents.
  • Burkean Sublime — This tradition links the sublime to terror that does not cause harm. It validates intense emotions after betrayal while encouraging safe exposure to truth, documentation, and paced support.
  • Catastrophic Realization — This is the moment when the truth breaks through denial. It explains sudden shakes, cold sweats, or nausea and supports immediate steps like hydration, slow breathing, and delaying decisions.
  • Catharsis Through Meaning — This process turns painful events into clear lessons. It guides victims to write timelines, name tactics, and draw practical boundaries that protect future choices.
  • Cognitive Anchors — These are small verified facts used to steady thinking during confusion. Examples include bank statements, call logs, and saved screenshots that help guide next actions.
  • Cognitive Overwhelm — This state arises when information exceeds mental bandwidth. It explains decision fog during scams and supports the use of checklists, pauses, and second opinions.
  • Cosmic Indifference — This theme highlights a vast world that does not adjust to personal pain. It validates grief while reminding readers to build local supports where care and accountability exist.
  • Cosmic Sublime — This experience involves confronting immensity beyond ordinary scale. It helps victims understand why the scope of organized fraud feels crushing and why small, steady actions matter.
  • Creative Reframing — This skill recasts events without denying facts. It replaces self-blame with accurate responsibility and turns learning into concrete safety steps.
  • Crisis of Meaning — This describes the emptiness that can follow a revealed lie. It encourages readers to keep routines, meet supportive people, and write a simple plan for the next day.
  • Deep-Time Perspective — This reframes a painful event within a longer life arc. It lowers urgency and helps readers choose measured repairs over impulsive responses.
  • Disenchantment Shock — This names the jolt when a convincing story falls apart. It suggests simple safeguards such as independent callbacks, video identity checks, and waiting periods for money movement.
  • Dynamical Sublime — This term describes awe at overwhelming force, such as storms or systems. It models how organized crime pressures attention and why structured routines restore control.
  • Embodied Alarm — This is the body’s surge of alert signals, like a tight chest or trembling. It justifies using physical resets such as walking, stretching, or paced exhale breathing.
  • Emotional Disillusionment — This reaction follows the collapse of trust and perceived reality. It is a normal phase that softens with clear naming, peer support, and verified information.
  • Emotional Regulation Capacity — This ability stabilizes mood under stress. It grows through breathing drills, sleep care, movement, and paced conversations with trusted allies.
  • Existential Reappraisal — This step reassesses beliefs about self, others, and safety after betrayal. It turns chaos into a new, practical philosophy that honors caution and hope.
  • Existential Vertigo — This captures the dizzy feeling when basic assumptions collapse. It points readers toward quiet spaces, supportive company, and verified information before making big choices.
  • Gothic Sublime — This literary mood uses darkness, mystery, and vast spaces to evoke awe. It mirrors the eerie feeling of staged personas and supports slow verification before commitment.
  • Grand-Scale Perspective — This widens the frame beyond one scam to broader patterns. It reduces self-blame and guides reporting to banks, platforms, and relevant authorities.
  • Horizon of Understanding — This refers to the current limit of what feels graspable. It normalizes learning in small units and returning later as strength and clarity grow.
  • Identity Fracture — This names the split between who a person believed they were and how they feel after betrayal. It supports gentle self-talk, updated boundaries, and trauma-informed counseling.
  • Illusion Collapse — This is the breakdown of a fabricated persona or story. It directs readers to archive evidence, stop contact, and secure accounts without seeking closure from the scammer.
  • Imaginative Transport — This effect occurs when a story pulls attention fully inside its world. It explains how scammers’ scripts feel convincing and why breaking the script with delays and checks works.
  • Imponderable Scale — This describes the sense that the operation felt larger than one person. It encourages contacting hotlines, support groups, and consumer protection agencies.
  • Kantian Mathematical Sublime — This idea concerns awe at the sheer magnitude that exceeds counting. It clarifies why the scale of online fraud feels numbing and suggests narrowing focus to the next verifiable step.
  • Liminal Safety — This is a transitional zone where old trust is gone and new trust is forming. It endorses cautious experiments with connection, clear consent, and privacy protections.
  • Longinian Sublime — This concept links elevated language to powerful emotional impact. It warns that stirring phrases can mask falsehoods and calls for source checks before action.
  • Lovecraftian Scale — This theme features human smallness before vast, hidden forces. It helps readers accept fear without paralysis and choose practical protections in daily life.
  • Metaphoric Mirror — This uses myth or literature to reflect modern deceit. It helps readers learn patterns without reliving details and practice safer responses.
  • Moral Shock — This moment arrives when facts expose deliberate cruelty. It often triggers anger and grief, which can be directed into reporting, advocacy, and boundary-setting.
  • Narrative Distance — This tool creates a little space between the person and the event. Writing in third person or by timeline helps organize facts and lowers shame.
  • Narrative Reclaiming — This is the act of telling the story in accurate, compassionate language. It replaces shame with facts and sets the stage for legal, financial, and emotional recovery.
  • Nature-Driven Awe — This is the steadying sense drawn from large natural scenes. It supports nervous system regulation through time outdoors, light movement, and regular sleep.
  • Overwhelm Threshold — This marks the point where thinking starts to loop. It calls for short breaks, water, a snack, and postponing complex tasks until calmer.
  • Perceptual Flood — This is an influx of details that prevents decision-making. It suggests turning big problems into lists of small, verifiable steps.
  • Personal Sublime — This experience is an intense, transformative encounter within one’s own life. It frames recovery as growth in clarity, boundaries, and self-respect after profound betrayal.
  • Poetic Elevation — This is language that lifts emotion and can blur judgment. It reminds readers to verify claims that arrive wrapped in stirring words or grand promises.
  • Power–Imbalance Awe — This names the pressure felt when facing organized schemes. It points to community reporting, pooled knowledge, and shared warnings to rebalance power.
  • Protective Skepticism — This habit questions claims while remaining respectful. It invites verification rituals, slower money decisions, and consultation with a trusted peer or advisor.
  • Recovery Sublime — This is the surprising dignity found while healing. It highlights tracking small wins, marking progress dates, and thanking helpers to strengthen momentum.
  • Reverent Distance — This practice keeps a respectful space from risky offers. It supports rules such as no urgent transfers, no secrecy, and third-party reviews.
  • Scale Mismatch — This is the gap between the scam’s reach and one person’s resources. It encourages using formal channels and accepting help rather than fixing everything alone.
  • Sense Boundary — This term marks the limit where perception stops making sense. Recognizing the boundary signals time to pause, ground, and obtain independent confirmation.
  • Sense-Making Spiral — This approach returns to a topic in layers to integrate new facts. It supports steady progress without forcing immediate closure.
  • Shock-to-Structure Path — This outlines moving from chaos to routine. It includes sleep stabilization, daily checklists, and scheduled support meetings.
  • Signal-from-Noise Practice — This teaches sorting real evidence from distraction. It recommends independent sources, cross-checks, and saved copies of all communications.
  • Storycraft Safeguards — These are tests applied to persuasive narratives. They include identity verification, provenance checks, and documented timelines.
  • Sublimis Etymology — The origin of “sublime” from Latin for “elevated” clarifies that rising above confusion is possible. It invites readers to pursue insight without rushing or denial.
  • Threshold Experience — This event pushes a person past former limits of belief or control. It motivates new safeguards, informed consent, and clearer financial boundaries.
  • Tidal Fear — This describes fear that rises and falls across the day. It supports planning tougher tasks after calming practices and finishing with a small, doable win.
  • Transcendent Appraisal — This re-evaluation sees pain alongside emerging strengths. It honors losses while identifying skills, allies, and routines that will carry recovery.
  • Transfixion Response — This is the freeze state that keeps someone scrolling or replying. It invites a hard stop, standing up, and contacting a safe person before the next step.
  • Trauma Integration — This process weaves hard memories into a workable life story. It uses therapy, peer groups, and daily structure to reduce triggers and improve decisions.
  • Trust Architecture — This is the set of rules that protects future interactions. It includes slow money policies, password managers, and two-factor authentication.
  • Trust Shatter Point — This instant marks the collapse of perceived safety. Planning for it includes preset refusal scripts, independent verification, and defined cooling-off times.
  • Uncanny Vastness — This feeling blends strangeness with immensity. It explains the chill of coordinated scams and supports focusing on concrete, local actions.
  • Unfathomable Otherness — This names the eerie strangeness of a fabricated identity. It reminds readers to privilege inconsistencies over charm when assessing risk.
  • Vastness Appraisal — This is the skill of judging how big a problem truly is. It breaks work into what must be done today, this week, and with outside help.
  • Wonder Response — This reaction opens curiosity after fear begins to ease. It helps readers re-engage with learning, community, and careful generosity while keeping safeguards in place.

Reference

The Sublime and Cognitive Dissonance

The concepts of the sublime and cognitive dissonance are both psychological phenomena that deal with the human mind’s response to conflicting or overwhelming experiences, albeit in different ways. Understanding their relationship can provide insights into how individuals process and reconcile profound, often contradictory, experiences.

Cognitive Dissonance

Cognitive dissonance refers to the mental discomfort experienced by a person who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, values, or ideas simultaneously. This discomfort motivates the individual to reduce the dissonance by changing one of the conflicting cognitions or adding new ones to make the conflicting beliefs more compatible.

For example, a person who believes in the importance of honesty might experience cognitive dissonance if they tell a lie to avoid hurting someone’s feelings. The dissonance arises from the conflict between their belief in honesty and their action of lying.

The Sublime

The sublime, as discussed earlier, involves experiences that are so vast, powerful, or profound that they overwhelm the senses and challenge our understanding of the world. It is an experience that lifts us beyond the mundane, transporting us to a realm where the boundaries of human perception and comprehension are pushed to their limits. The sublime can evoke a sense of awe, wonder, and sometimes, profound horror.

The Relationship Between the Sublime and Cognitive Dissonance

Overwhelming Experience and Dissonance:

  • Sublime: The experience of the sublime often involves a sense of being overwhelmed by something beyond ordinary comprehension. This can lead to a state of cognitive dissonance as the individual struggles to reconcile the overwhelming experience with their existing worldview and beliefs.
  • Example: A person who has a profound spiritual experience might find it difficult to integrate this experience with their previous secular worldview, leading to cognitive dissonance as they grapple with the new beliefs and perceptions.

Challenge to Existing Beliefs:

  • Sublime: The sublime often challenges our existing beliefs and perceptions, pushing us to question the very foundations of our understanding. This challenge can create cognitive dissonance as we struggle to reconcile the new, overwhelming experience with our established beliefs.
  • Example: Encountering a natural phenomenon that defies scientific explanation, such as a mysterious light in the sky, can create cognitive dissonance for someone who strongly believes in the rationality of the scientific method.

Emotional and Rational Conflict:

  • Sublime: The sublime often involves a conflict between emotional and rational responses. The awe and wonder we feel can be at odds with our rational understanding of the world, creating a form of cognitive dissonance.
  • Example: Standing at the edge of a vast canyon, one might feel a sense of awe and insignificance in the face of nature’s grandeur, which can conflict with their rational understanding of geological processes and the impersonal forces of nature.

Transformation and Reconciliation:

  • Sublime: The experience of the sublime can lead to personal transformation and a new understanding of the self and the world. This transformation often involves reconciling the overwhelming experience with one’s existing beliefs and perceptions, a process that can be seen as resolving cognitive dissonance.
  • Example: A person who has a near-death experience might undergo a profound transformation in their beliefs about life and death. This new understanding can create initial cognitive dissonance, but as they integrate the experience into their worldview, they resolve the dissonance and emerge with a more cohesive set of beliefs.

The Role of Awe and Terror:

  • Sublime: The sublime often involves a paradox of awe and terror, where the overwhelming experience can be both inspiring and frightening. This paradox can create cognitive dissonance as the individual struggles to reconcile the positive and negative aspects of the experience.
  • Example: Witnessing a powerful storm can evoke both awe at the beauty and power of nature and terror at its destructive potential. This dual response can create cognitive dissonance as the individual grapples with the conflicting emotions and perceptions.

The relationship between the sublime and cognitive dissonance lies in their shared exploration of the human mind’s response to overwhelming and contradictory experiences. The sublime pushes the boundaries of human perception and comprehension, often leading to a state of cognitive dissonance as individuals struggle to reconcile the overwhelming experience with their existing beliefs and perceptions. This dissonance can be a catalyst for personal transformation and growth, as individuals work to integrate the sublime experience into their worldview, resolving the conflict and emerging with a new understanding of themselves and the world around them. In this way, the sublime and cognitive dissonance are interconnected phenomena that highlight the complex and dynamic nature of human consciousness and the ongoing process of meaning-making in the face of the overwhelming and the unknown.

Author Biographies

Dr. Tim McGuinness is a co-founder, Managing Director, and Board Member of the SCARS Institute (Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.), where he serves as an unsalaried volunteer officer dedicated to supporting scam victims and survivors around the world. With over 34 years of experience in scam education and awareness, he is perhaps the longest-serving advocate in the field.

Dr. McGuinness has an extensive background as a business pioneer, having co-founded several technology-driven enterprises, including the former e-commerce giant TigerDirect.com. Beyond his corporate achievements, he is actively engaged with multiple global think tanks where he helps develop forward-looking policy strategies that address the intersection of technology, ethics, and societal well-being. He is also a computer industry pioneer (he was an Assistant Director of Corporate Research Engineering at Atari Inc. in the early 1980s) and invented core technologies still in use today. 

His professional identity spans a wide range of disciplines. He is a scientist, strategic analyst, solution architect, advisor, public speaker, published author, roboticist, Navy veteran, and recognized polymath. He holds numerous certifications, including those in cybersecurity from the United States Department of Defense under DITSCAP & DIACAP, continuous process improvement and engineering and quality assurance, trauma-informed care, grief counseling, crisis intervention, and related disciplines that support his work with crime victims.

Dr. McGuinness was instrumental in developing U.S. regulatory standards for medical data privacy called HIPAA and financial industry cybersecurity called GLBA. His professional contributions include authoring more than 1,000 papers and publications in fields ranging from scam victim psychology and neuroscience to cybercrime prevention and behavioral science.

“I have dedicated my career to advancing and communicating the impact of emerging technologies, with a strong focus on both their transformative potential and the risks they create for individuals, businesses, and society. My background combines global experience in business process innovation, strategic technology development, and operational efficiency across diverse industries.”

“Throughout my work, I have engaged with enterprise leaders, governments, and think tanks to address the intersection of technology, business, and global risk. I have served as an advisor and board member for numerous organizations shaping strategy in digital transformation and responsible innovation at scale.”

“In addition to my corporate and advisory roles, I remain deeply committed to addressing the rising human cost of cybercrime. As a global advocate for victim support and scam awareness, I have helped educate millions of individuals, protect vulnerable populations, and guide international collaborations aimed at reducing online fraud and digital exploitation.”

“With a unique combination of technical insight, business acumen, and humanitarian drive, I continue to focus on solutions that not only fuel innovation but also safeguard the people and communities impacted by today’s evolving digital landscape.”

Dr. McGuinness brings a rare depth of knowledge, compassion, and leadership to scam victim advocacy. His ongoing mission is to help victims not only survive their experiences but transform through recovery, education, and empowerment.

 

Please Rate This Article

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 3

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Since you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Please Leave Us Your Comment Below
Also, tell us of any topics we might have missed.

-/ 30 /-

What do you think about this?
Please share your thoughts in a comment above!

ARTICLE RATING

5
(3)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

CATEGORIES

U.S. & Canada Suicide Lifeline 988

The Sublime Experience of Betrayal - An Essay - 2025

ARTICLE META

Published On: November 3rd, 2025Last Updated: November 3rd, 2025Categories: EDITORIAL / COMMENTARY, • FEATURED ARTICLE, • FOR SCAM VICTIMS, • PHILOSOPHY, 2025, Tim McGuinness PhD0 Comments on The Sublime Experience of Betrayal – An Essay – 2025Total Views: 47Daily Views: 27042 words35.4 min read

Leave A Comment

Important Information for New Scam Victims

  • Please visit www.ScamVictimsSupport.org – a SCARS Website for New Scam Victims & Sextortion Victims.
  • SCARS Institute now offers its free, safe, and private Scam Survivor’s Support Community at www.SCARScommunity.org – this is not on a social media platform, it is our own safe & secure platform created by the SCARS Institute especially for scam victims & survivors.
  • SCARS Institute now offers a free recovery learning program at www.SCARSeducation.org.
  • Please visit www.ScamPsychology.org – to more fully understand the psychological concepts involved in scams and scam victim recovery.

If you are looking for local trauma counselors, please visit counseling.AgainstScams.org

If you need to speak with someone now, you can dial 988 or find phone numbers for crisis hotlines all around the world here: www.opencounseling.com/suicide-hotlines

 

 

Statement About Victim Blaming

Some of our articles discuss various aspects of victims. This is both about better understanding victims (the science of victimology) and their behaviors and psychology. This helps us to educate victims/survivors about why these crimes happened and not to blame themselves, better develop recovery programs, and help victims avoid scams in the future. At times, this may sound like blaming the victim, but it does not blame scam victims; we are simply explaining the hows and whys of the experience victims have.

These articles, about the Psychology of Scams or Victim Psychology – meaning that all humans have psychological or cognitive characteristics in common that can either be exploited or work against us – help us all to understand the unique challenges victims face before, during, and after scams, fraud, or cybercrimes. These sometimes talk about some of the vulnerabilities the scammers exploit. Victims rarely have control of them or are even aware of them, until something like a scam happens, and then they can learn how their mind works and how to overcome these mechanisms.

Articles like these help victims and others understand these processes and how to help prevent them from being exploited again or to help them recover more easily by understanding their post-scam behaviors. Learn more about the Psychology of Scams at www.ScamPsychology.org

 

SCARS INSTITUTE RESOURCES:

If You Have Been Victimized By A Scam Or Cybercrime

♦ If you are a victim of scams, go to www.ScamVictimsSupport.org for real knowledge and help

♦ SCARS Institute now offers its free, safe, and private Scam Survivor’s Support Community at www.SCARScommunity.org – this is not on a social media platform, it is our own safe & secure platform created by the SCARS Institute especially for scam victims & survivors.

♦ Enroll in SCARS Scam Survivor’s School now at www.SCARSeducation.org

♦ To report criminals, visit https://reporting.AgainstScams.org – we will NEVER give your data to money recovery companies like some do!

♦ Follow us and find our podcasts, webinars, and helpful videos on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@RomancescamsNowcom

♦ Learn about the Psychology of Scams at www.ScamPsychology.org

♦ Dig deeper into the reality of scams, fraud, and cybercrime at www.ScamsNOW.com and www.RomanceScamsNOW.com

♦ Scam Survivor’s Stories: www.ScamSurvivorStories.org

♦ For Scam Victim Advocates visit www.ScamVictimsAdvocates.org

♦ See more scammer photos on www.ScammerPhotos.com

You can also find the SCARS Institute’s knowledge and information on Facebook, Instagram, X, LinkedIn, and TruthSocial

Psychology Disclaimer:

All articles about psychology and the human brain on this website are for information & education only

The information provided in this and other SCARS articles are intended for educational and self-help purposes only and should not be construed as a substitute for professional therapy or counseling.

Note about Mindfulness: Mindfulness practices have the potential to create psychological distress for some individuals. Please consult a mental health professional or experienced meditation instructor for guidance should you encounter difficulties.

While any self-help techniques outlined herein may be beneficial for scam victims seeking to recover from their experience and move towards recovery, it is important to consult with a qualified mental health professional before initiating any course of action. Each individual’s experience and needs are unique, and what works for one person may not be suitable for another.

Additionally, any approach may not be appropriate for individuals with certain pre-existing mental health conditions or trauma histories. It is advisable to seek guidance from a licensed therapist or counselor who can provide personalized support, guidance, and treatment tailored to your specific needs.

If you are experiencing significant distress or emotional difficulties related to a scam or other traumatic event, please consult your doctor or mental health provider for appropriate care and support.

Also read our SCARS Institute Statement about Professional Care for Scam Victims – click here

If you are in crisis, feeling desperate, or in despair, please call 988 or your local crisis hotline.

A Question of Trust

At the SCARS Institute, we invite you to do your own research on the topics we speak about and publish. Our team investigates the subject being discussed, especially when it comes to understanding the scam victims-survivors’ experience. You can do Google searches, but in many cases, you will have to wade through scientific papers and studies. However, remember that biases and perspectives matter and influence the outcome. Regardless, we encourage you to explore these topics as thoroughly as you can for your own awareness.