My Dinner with André: A Comparison
A SCARS Institute Scam Victim Recovery Insight
Have you seen a movie called “My Dinner with André” (1981)?
In the movie, there is a profound philosophical question that might relate directly to your experience.
The thing is, though, this is difficult to examine from a psychological perspective but might be essential from a philosophical perspective.
If this makes no sense to you, then ignore it. But it is worth thinking about for a minute or two regardless.
André’s Paradox
In My Dinner with André, André Gregory wonders whether the 1960s were “the last burst of the human being before he was extinguished.” He imagines a future in which people go through the motions like robots and gradually lose the memory of what it felt like to live differently.
André’s idea is that a society organized around money, routine, and mass media can dull people’s ability to notice what is happening around them. Boredom matters to him because a person who has stopped paying attention is less likely to question what they are asked to accept. He sees the 1960s as a last surge of people questioning how they were expected to live. His bleakest thought is that later generations could lose even the memory that those expectations were once open to challenge.
The film gives that idea two answers. André describes small communities that could preserve memory, culture, and ways of living that the wider society was losing. Wally points to the life he already has: writing plays, spending time with Debby, and enjoying his morning coffee. Wally’s reply raises a question André takes seriously: if you are paying attention to the people and details of your ordinary life, why would you have to leave it to feel fully alive?
The Unbearable Life
Awareness can be unbearable. Some truths hurt precisely because you see them clearly. You can understand that a loss is permanent, that an injustice will go unanswered, or that you have very little power over something that matters deeply to you. Seeing it more clearly may deepen the pain because it takes away explanations that once made the situation easier to live with.
There is an idea that depression gives people a more accurate view of reality. Psychologists have tested a narrower version of that idea, called depressive realism. A preregistered study found no evidence that people with more depressive symptoms judged their control over an outcome more accurately. However, the larger philosophical question remains: what happens when you grasp something painful and it begins to shape what you expect from everything else? “I lost something I can never get back” can be entirely true. “Nothing will ever matter to me again” is a prediction about a future you haven’t lived.
That’s what makes Wally’s answer to André interesting. André sees a society losing its ability to feel and pay attention. Wally pays close attention to his own life: his time with his spouse, the work he enjoys, the coffee waiting for him in the morning. Those details do nothing to settle André’s argument about society. They do show that attention can bring you into contact with something worth caring about at the same time that it makes you more aware of what hurts.
Vacuum of Control
There is a phrase that I invented decades ago talking about product development that I called the “Vacuum of Control,” where in the process of creating anything, you eventually lose control, and the product or project takes on a life of its own.
The phrase “vacuum of control” names the gap between the scale of what you’re aware of and the scale of what you can change. You can follow a war, an injustice, or the decline of something you value in great detail and still have very little influence over what happens next. The more of your day that gap occupies, the more often you face the same experience: something matters deeply, and you can see no way to affect it. Anxiety can grow around what might happen next. Depressive thinking can take hold when “I can’t change this” begins to feel like “Nothing I do makes a difference.”
Small things bring your attention and your ability to act back into alignment. You make a meal and have something to eat. You call someone you miss and hear their voice. You finish a task that has been hanging over you and see the difference it makes to the rest of your day. The scale matters because the effect is close enough for you to experience it. There’s a parallel in behavioral activation, a treatment for depression that helps people reengage with meaningful activities and notice how what they do affects how they feel.
This gives Wally’s mention of his morning coffee more weight. His coffee is something he looks forward to, something he can arrange for himself, and something he actually enjoys when he wakes up. André is asking what has happened to humanity. Wally is paying attention to the part of human life he can still participate in that morning. Both scales matter. When the larger one makes you feel powerless, the smaller one gives you a place to experience your own influence again.
Applied to Scams
A scam creates a vacuum of control twice.
During the scam, the criminal makes it seem that what happens next depends on you. Send the payment and the person can come home. Solve this last problem and the future you planned together can begin. You take real actions with real consequences, while the criminal controls the story that tells you what those actions are supposed to achieve.
After discovery, that story falls apart, and you are left facing losses and decisions you have much less power over than you were led to believe.
That gap can take over your attention. You want your money back, answers from the bank, and accountability for the crime. You also want to understand how someone you trusted could do this to you. Those concerns deserve attention, but none offers a quick or certain result. When you spend hour after hour waiting, searching, or going over the same questions, the powerlessness of the crime can start to feel like a fact about your whole life. “I can’t make the bank return my money” becomes “Nothing I do matters.” The first statement describes a limit you face. The second carries that limit into parts of your life where you still have choices.
Recovery brings your attention back into alignment with what you can actually do. You can gather the records and file a report, even though someone else decides whether to investigate. You can tell a trusted person what happened and hear their response. You can make breakfast, step outside, or keep an appointment that matters to you. Each action gives you a different experience from the one the scam imposed. You decide what to do, you do it, and you see what follows. When shame tells you to stay silent, for example, telling one person and receiving a kind response gives you something concrete to remember the next time you feel alone.
That is where Wally’s morning coffee fits. After a scam, a quiet cup of coffee can be a part of the day you choose and enjoy for yourself. You can give the crime the time it needs, then give some of your day to a friend, a meal, or work that matters to you. In time, those choices can support larger ones, such as making a financial plan, rebuilding a friendship, or returning to something you stopped doing. You are rebuilding a life you can take part in now, while questions about money and justice are still open.
Keeping Recovery at a Scale You Can Manage
So here we loop this back around to the philosophy of recovery – a backbone of Recoverology.
Recovery becomes manageable when you bring it down to the size of an action you can finish.
“Recover from the scam” is too large to work on all at once. It includes money, grief, trust, and the routines the crime disrupted. When you sit down to face all of that together, even a useful first step can disappear inside the size of the problem. Give yourself a task with a clear end, such as finding the receipt for one payment, writing about one moment you keep returning to, or calling one person you trust.
Did you notice that part? Writing is a very small step. Yet it has a huge impact when it is done.
The scale of the task needs to fit the energy and attention you have today. If the paperwork overwhelms you, start by putting the records you already have in one place. If you have been avoiding a conversation, write the first sentence you want to say. When a task still feels too large, make it smaller until you know exactly where to begin and how you will know when you are finished. You have enough to do in that moment simply by carrying out the step you chose.
Finishing matters because it gives you direct experience of your own influence.
The scam taught you to act and then wait for a result the criminal controlled.
In recovery, it is often a result that you cannot see, that is too far in the future. So, break it down so you choose an action whose result you can see. You open the statement and record the date. You make the appointment and put it on the calendar. You tell someone what happened and end the day with one more person who knows. You write an entry in your journal and leave a comment on something you read. You reply to someone in the support community.
Each completed action changes a specific part of your situation and gives you a clearer place to begin next time.
Keeping the scale small also helps you stay with recovery over time. One day, you find and read an article. Then think about how it applied to what happened, how you are feeling now, and how you might use that information going forward.
The same principle applies to emotional recovery. Putting one painful moment into words gives you something specific to bring to a support conversation. As you work through those moments, you begin to understand what you miss, what still hurts, and where you need help.
The practical measure of a successful recovery day – not recovery overall – is whether you completed a step that serves your recovery. Once it is done, let it count. You can put down the papers, close the notebook, or go make the coffee you have been looking forward to. Tomorrow, you begin with the work you have already done behind you.
Postscript
I am not sure I would recommend that you watch “My Dinner with André“, I had to use a couple of rolls of duct tape to prevent my head from exploding, but there are profound insights in it. Should we add it here? Maybe.
The point, though, is this:
William Shakespeare wrote in Hamlet:
There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio,
Than are dreamt of in your philosophy.
What does it mean?
Hamlet’s line applies to the limits of the story you’re using to make sense of your life. During a scam, the criminal gives you an account in which every delay, emergency, and payment seems to fit. Cognitive poetics helps explain how that account becomes a world you can picture and act within. Shakespeare’s line reminds you that there is a world outside that account, and that some of the most important facts are the ones the story gives you no reason to look for.
After discovery, the same line applies in a different way. You see the betrayal, the loss, and the limits of what you can do about them. Those are real. But the conclusion “Nothing I do matters anymore” goes further than those facts allow. It takes what you know about the crime and uses it to predict the rest of your life.
That brings us back to André and Wally. André is looking at what he thinks humanity has lost. Wally’s coffee is a small piece of human life that André’s account leaves out: something Wally chooses, looks forward to, and enjoys. In recovery, making that coffee, calling one person, or finishing one task gives you a chance to encounter something your current picture of life may leave out, too. You do one thing within your reach and discover what actually follows. That gives you new evidence about your life at a time when the crime can feel like the only evidence you have.
Or so goes the theory …


