A Fake Social Media Scam But A Real Murder For Hire Plot In Alaska
How a Fake Social Media Profile Induced Teens Online to Commit a Murder for Hire!
Authors:
• SCARS Editorial Team – Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.
• Portions Alaska Department of Law, KTUU, and other sources
About This Article
The chilling murder-for-hire plot in Alaska involving Denali Dakota Skye Brehmer, which resulted in the tragic death of 19-year-old Cynthia Hoffman, highlights the dangerous consequences of online deception and manipulation, particularly in the context of ‘catfishing’ schemes.
Brehmer, along with her accomplices, was induced by an Indiana man, Darin Schilmiller, who offered a false promise of $9 million in exchange for photos and videos of Hoffman’s murder.
Despite not being the one to pull the trigger, Brehmer’s pivotal role in orchestrating the murder led to her sentencing of 99 years in prison.
The case raises concerns about the manipulation tactics employed online and the potential for vulnerable individuals, like Brehmer, to be coerced into committing heinous crimes.
As the details unfold, questions emerge about the extent of manipulation and control exerted by Schilmiller over Brehmer, underscoring the need for greater awareness and vigilance in combating online exploitation and crime.

The Strange Case of the ‘Catfish’ Murder of an Alaska Teen – Just Because They Could!
A young Alaska woman, 19-year-old Cynthia Hoffman was murdered near Thunderbird Falls in Chugiak, Alaska as a result of a social media fake profile.
The murder was carried out by Denali Dakota Skye Brehmer, who has been sentenced to 99 years in prison for her involvement in the chilling murder plot fueled by deception in an online ‘catfishing’ scheme, though the actual murder was performed by one of her companions Kayden McIntosh.
A third person, in Indiana, contracted for the murder through an impersonation scheme. That person, Darin Schilmiller, falsely promised Brehmer a staggering $9 million reward in exchange for photos and videos of Hoffman’s murder.
Court documents showed that Brehmer, then 18, struck up an online relationship with 21-year-old Darin Schilmiller, who was living in Indiana. Schilmiller claimed to be a millionaire and said he would send Brehmer $9 million in exchange for photos and videos of a killing. He did not name a target. Apparently, he solicited a murder just for fun using a fake social media profile to do it.
Brehmer allegedly offered four other friends a cut of the money if they helped her, and Brehmer and then-16-year-old Kayden McIntosh allegedly lured Hoffman (the murder victim) on a hike. During the hike, Hoffman was shot in the back of the head and put into a river by Kayden McIntosh. Police found Hoffman’s body one day after she was reported missing. McIntosh’s trial in the case is pending.
Brehmer, now 23, pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in February 2023 and has just been sentenced after charges of conspiracy to commit murder, solicitation of murder, tampering with evidence, and murder in the second degree were dismissed. Nearly a year later, her sentencing occurred over three days in January and February 2024. The 99-year sentence was the maximum penalty the court was permitted to impose, according to a news release from Alaska’s Department of Law.
Anchorage Superior Court Judge Andrew Peterson called Hoffman’s murder “tragic and senseless” and noted that Brehmer showed no remorse after the murder and went on to engage in other criminal conduct at Schilmiller’s request.
According to the U.S. Justice Department, Schilmiller and Brehmer also conspired to coerce a minor to produce sexually explicit images. Last summer, the two pleaded guilty to federal charges of conspiracy to produce child pornography.
Caleb Leyland, another friend involved in the murder-for-hire scheme, pleaded guilty to one charge of second-degree murder in November 2023 after charges of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder were dismissed. His sentencing is scheduled for June in front of the same judge who sentenced Brehmer.
McIntosh allegedly said that he “shot CeeCee” (the victim) and pushed her “twitching” body into a river, so he “does not know if she died from the gunshot wound or from drowning,” alleges the complaint.
In his final remarks earlier, McKay said that while Brehmer may not have fired the bullet that ended Cynthia’s life, she bore the brunt of the responsibility for the heinous act.
“She executed Cynthia Hoffman in a murder-for-hire plot. She conspired with numerous other individuals in and outside of Alaska, including juveniles, forever altering everybody’s life,” McKay, Jr. said at the sentencing hearing. “She may not have pulled the trigger, but this never would have happened it if it weren’t for Denali Brehmer.”
The Anchorage Police Department (APD) said in a statement that they later learned an Indiana man they identified as Darin Mitchell Schilmiller allegedly offered to pay Brehmer “$9 million or more to commit the murder and send him videos and/or photographs of the murder.”
Very Strange
Who is the accused contractor killer Darin Schilmiller? Former classmates of catfishing/impersonating ‘millionaire’-turned-murder suspect talk about disturbing past.
Darin Schilmiller, a 2017 graduate of North Harrison High School in Indiana is under arrest in a gruesome murder-for-hire killing carried out by teenagers in Alaska. State of Alaska prosecutors say 21-year-old Darin Schilmiller of New Salisbury, a small, rural farming community near Indiana’s southern border with Kentucky, “is one of the primary actors in Ms. Hoffman’s murder.”
It appears that he had a history of creating fake online profiles to lure in others. News media found numerous online profiles for Schilmiller spanning many years across multiple social media platforms. The common themes? A strong desire to find friends and connect with women.
According to one person who knew him “He didn’t want to do anything bad, he just didn’t understand life!”
The Murder of Cynthia Hoffman – Video courtesy of KTUU Alaska
Manipulation?
What we do not know in this case, because it was not mentioned in court was what, if any, manipulation was used by Schilmiller to control Brehmer.
However, knowing what we know about the psychology of online crime across social media, we have to wonder if manipulation was a factor. Could Brehmer have been controlled to engage in the acts involved in the murder? But we know it is certainly possible since scammers can manipulate victims into committing crimes all the time, though none (that we know of) is as severe as this one.
But that just raises more questions. Could there be other cases where teens can be manipulated into performing other types of crimes? Unfortunately, we will have to wait and see.
The Sentencing of Brehmer & Schilmiller
Brehmer, 23, received her sentence on Monday for her role in the tragic death of her best friend, Cynthia Hoffman. The crime unfolded after an Indiana man, In a disturbing turn of events, Brehmer and her accomplices lured Hoffman to a remote hiking trail before fatally shooting her in the head. Despite not pulling the trigger herself, Brehmer’s actions were pivotal in the execution of the crime. This case sheds light on the dangers of online deception and manipulation, emphasizing the devastating consequences of falling victim to catfishing schemes.
The charges against Schilmiller stem from the June 2, 2019 murder of 19-year-old Cynthia Hoffman near Thunderbird Falls in Chugiak, Alaska. The murder of Hoffman involved a group of teenagers who are accused of being “catfished” by Schilmiller, an Indiana resident, to commit the crime for money. As part of the agreement, Schilmiller signed an affidavit admitting to a statement of facts surrounding the incident. The case was investigated by the Anchorage Police Department and the Federal Bureau of Investigation, with the assistance of multiple other State and federal law enforcement agencies.
Darin Schilmiller Sentenced to 99 years for Murder of Cynthia Hoffman at Thunderbird Falls
According to the State of Alaska Department of Law:
25-year-old Darin Mitchell Schilmiller of New Salisbury, Indiana, was sentenced by Anchorage Superior Court Judge Andrew Peterson for the murder of 19-year-old Cynthia Hoffman near Thunderbird Falls in Chugiak, Alaska.
Schilmiller previously pleaded guilty to one count of Solicitation to Commit Murder in the First Degree. Evidence presented at sentencing shows that on June 2, 2019, Cynthia Hoffman was shot and killed on the banks of the Eklutna River near Thunderbird Falls. Afterward, Hoffman’s body was placed into the Eklutna River. Ultimately it was discovered that Schilmiller had solicited the murder of Hoffman from then 18-year-old Denali Brehmer in Anchorage. Schilmiller also solicited child pornography from Brehmer; conduct that led to additional charges by the U.S. Attorney’s Office.
Schilmiller’s sentencing occurred over three days. At sentencing, the State and Schilmiller both presented evidence. The court was permitted to sentence Schilmiller to a sentence of active imprisonment between 5 and 99 years. The State requested a sentence of 99 years with none suspended and an order restricting Schilmiller’s eligibility for discretionary parole. Schilmiller requested a sentence of 70 years with 20 years suspended. Several members of Cynthia Hoffman’s family provided victim impact statements at sentencing. Her father, Timothy Hoffman, described her as his “right hand man.” Her uncles described her as precious, vibrant, beautiful, and fun loving.
Judge Peterson called the case “extremely sad” and “shocking.” He described it as a premeditated murder-for-hire that was an “assassination” of Cynthia Hoffman. Judge Peterson found that Schilmiller’s conduct was among the most serious solicitation to commit first-degree murder cases and among the most serious contract killing cases. He further found that Schilmiller committed the murder “for the mere thrill of it.” Judge Peterson found Schilmiller was a “worst offender” for purposes of sentencing based on the conduct in this case and found that Schilmiller will “always be a risk to the community.” The court also expressed hope that the sentence would be a deterrence to others, recognizing that if it encourages one person to not commit a murder going forward, then it is a successful outcome.
Schilmiller was sentenced to 99 years with none suspended. In addition, he will not be eligible for discretionary parole until he has served at least 45 years of that sentence.
Multiple defendants were charged with causing Hoffman’s death. Denali Brehmer’s sentencing is scheduled for Feb. 12, 2024, in front of Judge Peterson. Caleb Leyland’s sentencing is scheduled for June 10, 2024, in front of Judge Peterson.
Kayden McIntosh’s case is pending trial. The charges against McIntosh are only allegations and are not evidence of guilt. The defendant is presumed innocent and is entitled to a fair trial at which the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
This case was investigated by the Anchorage Police Department’s homicide unit, the Federal Bureau of Investigation based out of Alaska and Indiana, and the Indiana State Police. Schilmiller is currently in the custody of the Alaska Department of Corrections.
Denali Brehmer Sentenced to 99 years for Murder of Cynthia Hoffman at Thunderbird Falls
According to the State of Alaska Department of Law:
A 23-year-old Denali Dakota Skye Brehmer, of Anchorage, was sentenced by Anchorage Superior Court Judge Andrew Peterson for the murder of Cynthia Hoffman near Thunderbird Falls in Chugiak, Alaska, on June 2, 2019.
Brehmer previously pleaded guilty to one count of Murder in the First Degree. Evidence presented at sentencing shows that on June 2, 2019, Cynthia Hoffman was shot and killed on the banks of the Eklutna River near Thunderbird Falls. Afterward, Hoffman’s body was placed into the Eklutna River. Ultimately it was discovered that Darin Schilmiller had solicited the murder of Hoffman from Brehmer in Anchorage. Schilmiller also solicited child pornography from Brehmer, conduct that led to additional federal charges.
Brehmer’s sentencing occurred over three days in January and February 2024. At sentencing, the State and Brehmer both presented evidence. The court was permitted to sentence Brehmer to a sentence of active imprisonment between 30 and 99 years. The State requested a sentence of 99 years with none suspended and a “worst offender” finding. Brehmer requested a sentence of 80 years with 20 years suspended.
“The Court should find that Miss Brehmer engaged in one of the most serious crimes that we have in Alaska,” McKay said. “She executed Cynthia Hoffman in a murder-for-hire plot. She conspired with numerous other individuals in and outside of Alaska, including juveniles, forever altering everybody’s life. She may not have pulled the trigger, but this never would have happened it if it weren’t for Denali Brehmer,” McKay said.
Judge Peterson called the murder of Cynthia Hoffman a premeditated murder-for-hire that was “tragic and senseless.” He stated that Brehmer’s conduct was “cold, calculated, and carried out to a ‘T’.” He found that Brehmer’s conduct was among the most serious first-degree murder cases and among the most serious contract killing cases. Judge Peterson described watching a video of Cynthia Hoffman’s last moments where she was observed duct taped on the ground at Thunderbird Falls “…one of the most difficult pieces of evidence I’ve had to watch in this position.” He noted that Brehmer showed no remorse after the murder and, in fact, went on to engage in other criminal conduct. The court also expressed hope that the sentence would be a deterrence to others.
Judge Peterson recognized that Brehmer was a youthful offender and that “youth matters” but found that Brehmer clearly knew what she was doing and that this was not some “youthful indiscretion.” Brehmer was sentenced to 99 years with none suspended and was found to be a “worst offender.”
Caleb Leyland’s sentencing is scheduled for June 10, 2024, in front of Judge Peterson.
Please Rate This Article
Please Leave Us Your Comment
Also, tell us of any topics we might have missed.
Thank you for your comment. You may receive an email to follow up. We never share your data with marketers.
-/ 30 /-
What do you think about this?
Please share your thoughts in a comment above!
More Related Information:
- Who is accused killer Darin Schilmiller? Former classmates of catfishing ‘millionaire’-turned-murder suspect talk about disturbing past (alaskasnewssource.com)
- U.S. Bank President Lured Into Pig Butchering Scam – Embezzled Almost $50 Million – 2024 (scamsnow.com)
- Stockholm Syndrome – Getting Scam Victims To Break The Law – 2024 (scamsnow.com)
- Cybercriminal Mole – UK Police Arrest One Of Their Own! (scamsnow.com)
- Scam Victim Commits Crimes For Their Scammers (scamsnow.com)
- Scam Victim’s Sacred Beliefs & Their Brain (scamsnow.com)
-/ 30 /-
What do you think about this?
Please share your thoughts in a comment above!
SCARS LINKS: AgainstScams.org RomanceScamsNOW.com ContraEstafas.org ScammerPhotos.com Anyscam.com ScamsNOW.com
reporting.AgainstScams.org support.AgainstScams.org membership.AgainstScams.org donate.AgainstScams.org shop.AgainstScams.org
youtube.AgainstScams.org linkedin.AgainstScams.org facebook.AgainstScams.org
TABLE OF CONTENTS
META
MOST POPULAR COMMENTED ARTICLES
POPULAR ARTICLES
WHAT PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT
LATEST SITE COMMENTS
See Comments for this Article at the Bottom of the Page
on Changing the Past and the Future – Scam Victims And the Bootstrap Paradox – 2025: “This entire article is so fascinating. And I did need a Tylenol at certain points! Seriously, it did give a…” Apr 27, 21:52
on Recognizing Fears After a Scam // Reconocer los Miedos Después de una Estafa – 2025: “After the scam, my emotional state was in a miserable state. Alone as never before in my life- lack of…” Apr 27, 15:03
on Changing the Past and the Future – Scam Victims And the Bootstrap Paradox – 2025: “Very interesting article. A key point, in the case of scams (or at least it was my case), is accepting…” Apr 27, 14:58
on Changing the Past and the Future – Scam Victims And the Bootstrap Paradox – 2025: “I had never heard of the Bootstrap Loop. I can see from this article that I am not psychologically pursuing…” Apr 27, 07:59
on Romance Scam/Fraud Can Be Local Not Just Online: “A stenographer who took down a lot of powerful people. Fascinating article.” Apr 25, 22:06
on Romance Scammers’ Favorite Lies Exposed: ““I have saved a lot of money, but my account is frozen. I need help making these transactions to my…” Apr 25, 21:53
on The Importance of Goal Setting for Scam Victims in Recovery – 2024: “The recovery journey seems daunting when you just think in all of the things you lost, the things you could…” Apr 25, 20:43
on Compassionate Reframing – a Very Important Recovery Tool for Scam Victims – 2025: “This article is very useful. Personally most of my thoughts were negative after the scam. SCARS lessons from the survivor’s…” Apr 25, 20:16
on Cruel Or Indifferent To Suffering – What Scammers Do And Why It Is So Important For Scam Victims To Understand – 2024: “We are truly sorry that you encounters hateful people, but WE are very proud to know you!” Apr 24, 21:07
on Helping Scam Victims To See Through Authority Bias To Expose The Scammers And Fraudsters For What They Are – 2024: “I love this in-the-moment thinking. The above questions could help in so many situations, bank-related and not. The pause needed…” Apr 24, 18:40
on Scam Victims Compliance With Scammer Authority Figures – 2024: “Understanding the various biases targeted by anyone portraying a police officer, government official or really any authority figure is helpful.…” Apr 24, 18:26
on Sleep Deprivation As A Scammer’s Control Technique And Its Effect On Scam Victims – 2024: “This time, one year ago, I was being kept awake about 20 hours a day. Being woken up at all…” Apr 24, 18:09
on Indoctrination Of Scam Victims By Their Scammers? Yes! – 2024: “Many of these examples were used on me and they certainly kept me coming back to them. As I read…” Apr 24, 16:35
on Glimmers of Light – the Positive Side of Experience for Scam Victims – 2025: “Glimmers – each of us can and should find such things in our lives that give us some joy, help…” Apr 24, 14:29
on Cruel Or Indifferent To Suffering – What Scammers Do And Why It Is So Important For Scam Victims To Understand – 2024: “I am Asian American. I suffered discrimination since emigrated to the USA in the late ‘70s. I’ve had human fecal…” Apr 24, 12:38
on The Scout Mindset And Scam Victims: “Very informative article that helps me to see how my thinking is a bit more Scout versus Soldier. But there…” Apr 24, 10:12
on Contractualism and Supporting the Victims of Online Crime: “So often in our lives we do not apply the concept of contractualism. We do not specifically “see” that each…” Apr 23, 14:46
on Scam Victims: Applying Boundaries When Compassion Is Required Instead – 2023: “If there is one thing my crime has taught me is that I had a very limited toolbox for dealing…” Apr 23, 13:34
on Understanding the Right Priorities – Another View of New Scam Victims’ Challenges – 2024: “In my case, not knowing about scams, the kind of people and manipulation that I dealed with, not knowing how…” Apr 22, 20:43
on The Courage it Takes to Recover from a Scam – For Scam Victims in Recovery – 2025: “After the scam I thought that almost everything was about what I lost and just a bit about what took…” Apr 22, 20:24
Important Information for New Scam Victims
Please visit www.ScamVictimsSupport.org – a SCARS Website for New Scam Victims & Sextortion Victims
SCARS Institute now offers a free recovery program at www.SCARSeducation.org
Please visit www.ScamPsychology.org – to more fully understand the psychological concepts involved in scams and scam victim recovery
If you are looking for local trauma counselors, please visit counseling.AgainstScams.org
If you need to speak with someone now, you can dial 988 or find phone numbers for crisis hotlines all around the world here: www.opencounseling.com/suicide-hotlines
Statement About Victim Blaming
Some of our articles discuss various aspects of victims. This is both about better understanding victims (the science of victimology) and their behaviors and psychology. This helps us to educate victims/survivors about why these crimes happened and not to blame themselves, better develop recovery programs, and help victims avoid scams in the future. At times, this may sound like blaming the victim, but it does not blame scam victims; we are simply explaining the hows and whys of the experience victims have.
These articles, about the Psychology of Scams or Victim Psychology – meaning that all humans have psychological or cognitive characteristics in common that can either be exploited or work against us – help us all to understand the unique challenges victims face before, during, and after scams, fraud, or cybercrimes. These sometimes talk about some of the vulnerabilities the scammers exploit. Victims rarely have control of them or are even aware of them, until something like a scam happens, and then they can learn how their mind works and how to overcome these mechanisms.
Articles like these help victims and others understand these processes and how to help prevent them from being exploited again or to help them recover more easily by understanding their post-scam behaviors. Learn more about the Psychology of Scams at www.ScamPsychology.org
SCARS INSTITUTE RESOURCES:
IF YOU HAVE BEEN VICTIMIZED BY A SCAM OR CYBERCRIME
♦ If you are a victim of scams, go to www.ScamVictimsSupport.org for real knowledge and help
♦ Enroll in SCARS Scam Survivor’s School now at www.SCARSeducation.org
♦ To report criminals, visit https://reporting.AgainstScams.org – we will NEVER give your data to money recovery companies like some do!
♦ Sign up for our free support & recovery help by https://support.AgainstScams.org
♦ Join our WhatsApp Chat Group at: https://chat.whatsapp.com/BPDSYlkdHBbDBg8gfTGb02
♦ Follow us on X: https://x.com/RomanceScamsNow
♦ Follow us and find our podcasts, webinars, and helpful videos on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@RomancescamsNowcom
♦ SCARS Institute Songs for Victim-Survivors: https://www.youtube.com/playlist…
♦ See SCARS Institute Scam Victim Self-Help Books at https://shop.AgainstScams.org
♦ Learn about the Psychology of Scams at www.ScamPsychology.org
♦ Dig deeper into the reality of scams, fraud, and cybercrime at www.ScamsNOW.com and www.RomanceScamsNOW.com
♦ Scam Survivor’s Stories: www.ScamSurvivorStories.org
♦ For Scam Victim Advocates visit www.ScamVictimsAdvocates.org
♦ See more scammer photos on www.ScammerPhotos.com
You can also find the SCARS Institute on Facebook, Instagram, X, LinkedIn, and TruthSocial
Psychology Disclaimer:
All articles about psychology and the human brain on this website are for information & education only
The information provided in this and other SCARS articles are intended for educational and self-help purposes only and should not be construed as a substitute for professional therapy or counseling.
Note about Mindfulness: Mindfulness practices have the potential to create psychological distress for some individuals. Please consult a mental health professional or experienced meditation instructor for guidance should you encounter difficulties.
While any self-help techniques outlined herein may be beneficial for scam victims seeking to recover from their experience and move towards recovery, it is important to consult with a qualified mental health professional before initiating any course of action. Each individual’s experience and needs are unique, and what works for one person may not be suitable for another.
Additionally, any approach may not be appropriate for individuals with certain pre-existing mental health conditions or trauma histories. It is advisable to seek guidance from a licensed therapist or counselor who can provide personalized support, guidance, and treatment tailored to your specific needs.
If you are experiencing significant distress or emotional difficulties related to a scam or other traumatic event, please consult your doctor or mental health provider for appropriate care and support.
Also read our SCARS Institute Statement about Professional Care for Scam Victims – click here
If you are in crisis, feeling desperate, or in despair, please call 988 or your local crisis hotline.
More ScamsNOW.com Articles
A Question of Trust
At the SCARS Institute, we invite you to do your own research on the topics we speak about and publish. Our team investigates the subject being discussed, especially when it comes to understanding the scam victims-survivors’ experience. You can do Google searches, but in many cases, you will have to wade through scientific papers and studies. However, remember that biases and perspectives matter and influence the outcome. Regardless, we encourage you to explore these topics as thoroughly as you can for your own awareness.
Leave a Reply