Positivity Can Be a Form of Gaslighting

”You’re Fine” – How Gaslighting, Toxic Positivity, and Peer Group Denial Harm Scam Victims

Primary Category: Scam Victim Recovery Psychology

Author:
•  Tim McGuinness, Ph.D., DFin, MCPO, MAnth – Anthropologist, Scientist, Polymath, Director of the Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.

About This Article

When you survive a scam, you carry real emotional injuries, confusion, grief, shame, and fear, and positivity can easily become gaslighting. You deserve validation and care, not denial. Yet many scam victims are told by peer groups, friends, or family that they are “fine,” that they should “move on,” or that “others have it worse.” These phrases may seem supportive, but they act as subtle forms of gaslighting. They cause you to doubt your emotions, suppress your pain, and question your reality. In peer-led groups without professional guidance, this often turns into a pressure to appear strong, recovered, or positive, even when you are still hurting. This emotional invalidation delays recovery, increases shame, and makes you feel isolated. Healing does not come from pretending. It begins when someone acknowledges your pain, gives it space, and helps you work through it. Professional psychological support gives you the tools, structure, and clarity to understand what happened and move forward with honesty and strength. You do not need to minimize your trauma to overcome it. You just need truth, support, and time to heal without pressure.

Note: This article is intended for informational purposes and does not replace professional medical advice. If you are experiencing distress, please consult a qualified mental health professional.

You’re Fine”: How Positive Gaslighting, Toxic Positivity, and Peer Group Denial Harm Scam Victims

Introduction to Positive Gaslighting

Positive Gaslighting seems harmless, but it is anything but. After surviving a scam and experiencing betrayal trauma, you feel overwhelmed, disoriented, and emotionally raw. You struggle with grief, shame, fear, or confusion. These reactions are normal, even if they feel painful, uncomfortable, or unfamiliar. Yet instead of receiving understanding or support, you often hear phrases like “you’re fine,” “just move on,” or “it could have been worse.” People around you might tell you to stay positive, focus on the future, or take comfort in the fact that you survived. On the surface, these words may seem encouraging. In reality, they often deepen your pain.

When someone tells you that you are okay while you feel anything but okay, it creates a split inside you. Part of you knows that something is wrong. You feel emotionally shaken, unsteady, and unsure of what to do next. At the same time, you are told by others that there is no problem. That contradiction does not calm your nervous system. It adds confusion, frustration, and doubt. You start to question your own perception of reality. You may wonder if you are overreacting or being weak. This internal conflict does not help you heal. It makes you feel more alone.

This problem is especially common in scam victim recovery spaces that lack professional leadership. Peer-led groups without trauma-informed guidance can become echo chambers of denial and toxic positivity. These spaces often reward surface-level optimism and discourage honest emotional processing. You might feel pressure to present yourself as strong or healed even when you are not. In these environments, expressions of real pain are sometimes dismissed as negativity or self-pity. What starts as encouragement becomes a subtle but damaging form of invalidation.

This dynamic is not limited to support groups. Friends and family members also repeat the message that “you’re okay” or “time heals all wounds.” They may mean well, but their words can unintentionally silence you. They might feel uncomfortable with your pain or not know how to respond. Rather than admit their discomfort, they try to cheer you up. They offer false reassurance, thinking it will help. Instead, it creates distance and makes you feel misunderstood.

This kind of repeated emotional invalidation can act like gaslighting, even when it is unintentional. It tells you to deny what you feel. When combined with toxic positivity, it becomes a powerful barrier to healing. You deserve to feel what you feel and to heal with truth and honesty, not denial or minimization.

What Happens When Your Pain Is Denied

When you are in emotional distress and someone tells you that you are fine, something inside you begins to unravel. You feel your emotions clearly. You know you are overwhelmed, afraid, or disoriented. Yet the words you hear contradict your reality. “You’re fine.” “You’re strong.” “It’s not that bad.” These phrases may sound supportive on the surface, but they often land like quiet invalidations. In that moment, your experience is not just minimized, it is erased. This is what gaslighting does.

This denial creates emotional dissonance. You feel something deeply, but someone you trust insists that what you feel is not real. That mismatch between your inner truth and their external message produces confusion. You start to question your own perception. “Maybe I am overreacting. Maybe I am weak.” That internal questioning often turns into self-doubt. You begin to wonder if your feelings are wrong or unjustified. Over time, this can erode your confidence and disconnect you from your emotional clarity.

The more this happens, the more you struggle to validate your own distress. You might hesitate to talk about your pain. You may start to feel shame for needing support. Instead of healing, you suppress. That suppression does not make the pain go away. It simply pushes it deeper, where it festers as anxiety, fatigue, or irritability. You may smile and nod while inside you feel like screaming. You may try to cope alone, because it feels like no one believes you are hurting.

This is not just casual dismissiveness. It can become a form of psychological distortion caused by positive gaslighting. You are told again and again that your perception is wrong. That pattern chips away at your sense of emotional stability. You stop trusting your instincts. You stop reaching out. You start to feel alone, not just in your pain, but in your ability to recognize what is real.

When your pain is denied, the wound deepens. It does not matter whether the denial comes from a well-meaning friend, an online support group, or a family member trying to stay positive. The effect is the same: you feel invisible. That invisibility can be more painful than the original trauma. You need more than encouragement. You need acknowledgment. You need space to feel what you feel, without correction, dismissal, or denial. That is where real healing begins.

What Gaslighting Really Is and What It Does to You

Gaslighting is a psychological manipulation tactic (intentional or unintentional) where someone tries to make you doubt your own perception, memory, or emotions. They do this by repeatedly denying what happened, minimizing your feelings, or telling you that your reactions are not real or irrational. Over time, this kind of manipulation can make you question your own mind. You begin to wonder if you misunderstood events, overreacted, or imagined the harm entirely.

The term “gaslighting” comes from the 1944 film ‘Gaslight’, in which a husband slowly manipulates his wife into believing she is losing her sanity by changing small things in their environment and then insisting she is imagining it. In real life, gaslighting may not involve a deliberate plot. It can happen subtly, especially when people around you consistently reject your emotional truth.

Author’s Note: It is important to remember that “your truth” may in fact, not be truth at all. That is where a professional will help you.

When someone tells you “that didn’t happen,” “you’re too sensitive,” or “you always think the worst,” you may begin to feel lost in your own mind. You know something felt wrong, but now you are unsure. That uncertainty eats away at your confidence. The problem is not just that someone lied. The real damage comes from repeated emotional invalidation. Each time you accept their version of reality over your own, your self-trust weakens.

Psychologically, gaslighting affects your ability to form accurate self-assessments. Your brain depends on feedback from your environment to understand experiences and make decisions. When someone constantly interrupts that process with distortion, you lose the clarity that allows you to respond to life with confidence. You start to depend on outside voices to tell you what is real. That dependence creates vulnerability. It leaves you exposed to more manipulation.

Emotionally, gaslighting produces confusion, shame, and chronic self-doubt. You might start avoiding conflict because you no longer trust your reactions. You may keep quiet, even when something feels wrong, just to avoid being told you are overreacting. In this state, you become disconnected from your inner voice. The longer it continues, the harder it becomes to identify what you really feel.

Gaslighting does not only come from abusers. It can happen in families, social groups, or even online spaces that push a narrow version of acceptable emotion. If someone tells you “you’re fine” when you are clearly struggling, that is gaslighting in disguise. Your feelings are real. Your pain deserves space. You do not need someone to rewrite your truth. You need someone who will listen.

Note that gaslighting is a process, not an intention. Gaslighting can be used by good people who are trying to help, or by someone trying to control you. But in either case, it denies your reality and causes harm.

Gaslighting in Peer-Led Scam Victim Groups

When you join a support group after a scam, you expect understanding, safety, and emotional honesty. Many groups do provide that. However, in peer-led groups without professional guidance, a different pattern often emerges. These spaces may begin with good intentions, but they often drift into what feels like a shared performance of strength, recovery, and positivity; essentially a toxic positivity and false encouragement echo chamber. If you express pain or confusion that does not match that tone, the group may push back, not with violence, but with minimization, deflection, or false encouragement. That pattern creates a kind of group gaslighting.

In these groups, members often repeat phrases like “you’re stronger than you think,” “it’s time to move forward,” or “don’t give them more power by staying upset.” On the surface, these messages sound supportive. Underneath, they send a different message: your pain is not welcome here. If you feel grief months after the scam, if you still cry at night, or if you question whether you can ever trust again, the group may respond with awkward silence or gently tell you to “stay positive.”

Author’s Note: Let’s look at this phrase as an example “you’re stronger than you think.” What that phrase is saying is that it is your perception that is wrong – the ‘think’ part means you have to change your thinking, instead of saying “You are stronger than you know,” which means that you have yet to discover your inner strength, whatever that may be. You can see how one word can change the intent.

Over time, that climate creates an emotional echo chamber. Everyone learns to repeat the acceptable language, words about healing, empowerment, and control, even if they do not feel those things yet. You may find yourself saying “I’m doing better now” when you are still struggling, just to avoid being singled out or dismissed. This is not just group encouragement. It becomes a form of collective denial.

That denial turns into collective gaslighting when your real emotions are not just ignored, but actively contradicted. You say “I still feel broken,” and someone replies “No, you’re fine.” You say “I’m not ready to trust people again,” and they tell you “You’re letting the scammer win.” These moments may seem small, but they compound over time. You start to second-guess your own experience. You wonder if you are weak or dramatic. You may feel shame for not bouncing back like others seem to have done.

This pattern damages your recovery in several ways. First, it teaches you to suppress your real emotions to fit into the group. That suppression does not make pain disappear. It pushes it deeper, where it festers as self-doubt and quiet despair. Second, it severs your trust in your inner world. If you cannot talk about your sadness without being corrected, you begin to doubt whether your sadness is valid. That loss of self-trust makes healing harder. It isolates you from your own mind. Third, the experience of group gaslighting increases shame. You start to believe that something is wrong with you, not because you were scammed, but because you still hurt when others claim they do not.

These outcomes do not mean that peer-led groups are always harmful; many are great. They serve a purpose, especially in early stages when you need connection and reassurance. The risk comes when the group replaces individual truth or professional support with a fixed recovery script. Without trained facilitators who can hold space for grief, anger, and confusion, the group often defaults to what feels easiest: pretend strength and forced optimism.

You deserve better than that. You need a space where all your emotions are allowed, even the messy and inconvenient ones. If your group silences you, shames you, or pressures you to smile through pain, that is not support. That is emotional control. That is gaslighting wrapped in community language. Your truth matters. You do not have to choose between being honest and being accepted. Find people who allow both.

The Subtle Difference

When someone suffers betrayal trauma from a scam, the way others respond can either support recovery or make things worse. Validation means you recognize and respect the person’s emotional state without trying to change it; you allow them to feel what they need to feel. It creates safety, trust, and space for healing. False encouragement, on the other hand, often sounds positive on the surface, but underneath it invalidates the person’s emotions. It pushes them to suppress pain, feel ashamed of distress, or rush their recovery to meet someone else’s expectations. In scam victim recovery, this difference matters. The wrong words, even well-intended, can deepen shame, reinforce silence, or trigger withdrawal.

Below are examples that show how validation and false encouragement differ. Each pair addresses the same emotion or situation but takes a very different approach.

Validation vs. False Encouragement

Many will not agree with this, but this is the difference between “positivism” and psychology. Truth vs. Gaslighting (regardless of the intention.)

As sayings:

• • Validation: “It makes sense that you feel overwhelmed after everything that happened.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’ve got to stop thinking about it and focus on the future.”
  • Validation: “That experience shook your trust. It’s okay if you still don’t feel safe.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’ll feel safe again soon, just think positively.”
  • Validation “You were manipulated. That doesn’t mean you’re weak.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’re stronger than this. Snap out of it.”
  • Validation: “Anyone in your position would feel confused and betrayed.”
    • False Encouragement: “Don’t let this define you, just move on.”
  • Validation: “It’s normal to grieve what you thought was real.”
    • False Encouragement: “You should be grateful it wasn’t worse.”
  • Validation: “Your emotions are valid, even if they don’t make sense right now.”
    • False Encouragement: “Try not to dwell on the negative.”
  • Validation: “You’re not overreacting. This trauma runs deep.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’re giving that scammer too much power by staying upset.”
  • Validation: “You have every right to feel ashamed, but that shame isn’t yours to carry.”
    • False Encouragement: “Let it go, it’s just baggage.”
  • Validation: “What you’re feeling is part of the healing process.”
    • False Encouragement: “You should be better by now.”
  • Validation: “You’re not alone. Other people feel this too, even if they don’t say it.”
    • False Encouragement: “Everyone goes through stuff like this. Get over it.”
  • Validation: “It’s okay if you don’t want to trust people yet.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’ll never grow unless you start trusting again.”
  • Validation: “You don’t need to justify your pain. It’s real.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’re just being too sensitive.”
  • Validation: “Recovery is messy. There’s no right pace.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’re healing wrong if you’re still this upset.”
  • Validation: “You’re allowed to feel angry about what happened.”
    • False Encouragement: “Anger just hurts you more. Stay positive.”
  • Validation: “Feeling broken doesn’t mean you are broken.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’re not broken. Don’t say that about yourself.”
  • Validation: “You’re trying your best, and that matters.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’re fine. You just don’t see it yet.”
  • Validation: “This still hurts you, and that’s okay.”
    • False Encouragement: “You need to move past this already.”
  • Validation: “You have a right to speak about what happened to you.”
    • False Encouragement: “Talking about it just keeps you stuck.”
  • Validation: “Your feelings don’t need fixing, they need space.”
    • False Encouragement: “You’re making this harder by focusing on the negative.”
  • Validation: “You get to define what recovery looks like for you.”
    • False Encouragement: “You should be more like the others who already moved on.”

As Affirmations

• • Validation: “It was not your fault.”
    • False encouragement: “You just made a mistake, everyone does. It’s time to stop blaming yourself.”
  • Validation: “You are a survivor.”
    • False encouragement: “You survived this, now move on.”
  • Validation: “You are stronger than you know.”
    • False encouragement: “You are stronger than you think. You’re too strong to let this keep bothering you. You should be past this.”
  • Validation: “You are not alone.”
    • False encouragement: “Other people have gone through worse. You’re not the only one, so try to be grateful.”
  • Validation: “Axios – You are worthy”
    • False encouragement: “You need to start acting like someone who values themselves. No more negativity.”
  • Validation: “This is truth.”
    • False encouragement: “You just need to accept the truth and stop focusing on how it made you feel.”

These differences may seem small, but they carry real emotional weight. Scam victims who hear repeated false encouragement often feel ashamed of their trauma, doubt their feelings, or retreat from support. When you validate instead, you offer them something solid: a truthful, respectful acknowledgment of their experience. That is the foundation of real healing.

Toxic Positivity as Emotional Sabotage

Toxic positivity happens when people push positive thinking in a way that ignores or dismisses your pain. It often sounds like encouragement, but it creates pressure to hide how you really feel. You hear phrases like “just stay positive,” “everything happens for a reason,” or “you’re stronger than this.” These words may seem kind on the surface, but when you are hurting, they feel hollow. You begin to question whether your pain is acceptable or whether you’re just supposed to pretend everything is fine.

This kind of forced optimism becomes a subtle form of emotional sabotage. It sends the message that your real feelings make others uncomfortable or that expressing pain is a sign of weakness. When someone tells you “look on the bright side” right after you’ve experienced betrayal, what they are really saying is, “I don’t want to hear about your pain.” Instead of feeling supported, you feel silenced.

Toxic positivity does not help you heal. It shuts down grief, stops honest conversation, and blocks access to proper support. You might start to feel ashamed for still struggling, even though your experience was traumatic. You may ask yourself, “What’s wrong with me? Why can’t I move on like everyone else?” That self-doubt can lead to isolation and emotional suppression. Instead of working through the pain, you push it down, which only extends your suffering.

You need space to tell the truth about what happened to you. Positive thinking has a place in recovery, but not at the cost of honesty. Real healing begins when someone says, “I see that this hurts. Let’s sit with it together.” That kind of validation gives you the strength to move forward, not by denying your emotions, but by facing them with clarity and support. When you are allowed to grieve, you gain the ability to grow. Toxic positivity blocks that growth by replacing real empathy with surface-level slogans. Healing requires more than that. It requires truth.

When Friends and Family Say “You’re Fine” or “Time Heals All Wounds”

After a scam, you may expect your friends or family to support you through the emotional fallout. Instead, you might hear phrases like “you’re fine,” “just try to move on,” or “time heals all wounds.” These comments often come from people who want to help but do not know how. Their discomfort with emotional pain leads them to say what sounds hopeful, even when it feels dismissive.

When someone you trust tells you that you are “strong enough to move past it,” it might sound encouraging to them. To you, it can feel like a refusal to acknowledge what you are actually going through. You are left wondering whether your emotions are too much or whether your reactions are somehow wrong. That doubt adds confusion to your grief and makes it harder to trust your own instincts.

This kind of emotional dismissal, even when well-intended, creates isolation. You start to second-guess your pain. You may stop sharing how you feel, especially if those around you keep insisting that “you’re overthinking it” or “you’ll feel better soon.” Over time, that gap between what you feel and what others say grows into alienation. You no longer feel seen or understood, even by the people closest to you.

The scam has already fractured your sense of trust. When loved ones deny your reality, it deepens that split. You may feel like you are carrying the emotional weight alone. This makes healing more difficult. Emotional support works best when someone says, “I believe you. I see how hard this is.” Denial, no matter how gentle it sounds, reinforces shame. Real care begins with listening, not correcting. You deserve responses that match the depth of what you are feeling.

Why Professional Help Is Essential

Scam trauma is not something you can simply shake off or ignore. It changes the way you think, feel, and trust, often in ways that are difficult to explain to others. You may feel shame, confusion, sadness, anger, or isolation, and all of that is valid. These emotional responses are not signs of weakness. They are symptoms of real psychological harm. That harm deserves care, not dismissal.

You might hear people say you just need time or that you should move on, but real healing requires more than time. It requires the right tools. A trauma-informed therapist helps you name your experience, understand what happened, and begin to integrate it into your life without letting it define you. You learn how to process emotions, regain clarity, and rebuild trust, in yourself and in others.

Support groups and peer communities can help, but they are not a replacement for licensed psychological care. Friends and fellow victims may mean well, but they are not trained to guide you through trauma. They cannot diagnose emotional injuries, offer structured treatment, or help you unravel complex psychological reactions. Only professionals can do that.

When you work with a trained therapist, you gain a safe space to be fully honest without being silenced or rushed. You also benefit from strategies that are grounded in research, not opinion. This kind of support gives you the structure and stability needed to recover in a healthy way. You stop surviving and start healing.

Choosing professional help is not a sign that something is wrong with you. It is a sign that you are ready to take your recovery seriously. It is how you begin to reclaim your life, with guidance that respects your pain and leads you out of it. You deserve that kind of support.

When a Professional Corrects You

Hearing correction from a licensed mental health professional can feel uncomfortable, especially when you are emotionally raw. You might interpret their words as invalidating or harsh. It can sound like they are minimizing your pain or contradicting your version of events. However, their role is not to agree with every thought you have. Their job is to help you recover, and that includes pointing out when your beliefs or perceptions may be distorting your healing process.

A therapist or trauma-informed specialist helps you examine what is true, what is helpful, and what may be keeping you stuck. This guidance is not a form of gaslighting. It is a structured and compassionate attempt to realign you with reality in a way that supports emotional recovery. Even if it feels upsetting in the moment, professional correction is part of rebuilding mental clarity, emotional resilience, and a healthier sense of self after betrayal.

Reclaiming Your Reality and Learning to Climb Out

What you feel is real. Your pain, confusion, anger, and grief are not exaggerations or weaknesses. They are valid responses to a betrayal that targeted your trust and your humanity. When someone tells you that you are fine or that you should just move on, they are not seeing the full depth of what you experienced. You do not have to silence your emotions to appear strong. Real strength begins with honesty.

You may feel grief, rage, shame, fear, or numbness. These feelings often come in waves. Some days may feel manageable. Others may hit without warning. That emotional chaos is not a sign that something is wrong with you. It is evidence that something wrong happened to you.

Your path forward starts by understanding your emotions instead of avoiding them. In the short term, you can learn ways to manage the intensity, through breathing, grounding, and support. In the long term, you will begin to rebuild the deeper parts of your life: your trust, your identity, and your emotional resilience.

You are not broken. You were deeply wounded by deception and betrayal. That wound will heal through acknowledgment, truth, and care, not denial. You do not need to fake peace or pretend to be fine. What you need is the space to feel, to understand, and to climb out, step by step, on your terms.

Conclusion

Why Radical Truth, Honesty, Not Denial, Heals Scam Victims

Recovery from scam trauma begins with truth. When others tell you that you are fine, that you should move on, or that staying positive is all you need, they may not see how much those words hurt. Dismissive reassurance, toxic positivity, and peer pressure to perform healing do not support your recovery. They sabotage it. Even if people mean well, their refusal to acknowledge your pain can deepen your confusion and isolate you from the help you actually need.

You deserve more than surface-level comfort. You deserve to feel what you feel, without pressure to hide it. Your pain is real, your emotions are valid, and your reactions make sense. The voices that deny your experience, even softly, are not helping. They are asking you to abandon yourself to make others more comfortable.

Real recovery does not happen through denial. It happens when you work with someone who respects your truth and knows how to guide you through it. That is why professional support is essential. You do not have to stay stuck in shame or silence. You can learn to trust yourself again. You can heal without pretending. You can move forward with clarity, courage, and honesty, on your terms.

Afterthought: The Difference Between Encouragement and Emotional Distortion

Toxic positivity and false encouragement often get confused with motivational speaking. The difference lies in who the message is for. Motivational messages can lift and inspire people who are emotionally stable, not in crisis, and ready to take action. Those individuals may benefit from phrases like “you’ve got this” or “focus on the positive.” These messages assume the listener has emotional bandwidth and mental clarity to put the words into action.

Traumatized people are in a different state. Scam victims often feel disoriented, ashamed, and emotionally raw. When you hear messages like “look on the bright side” or “you’re stronger than this,” it does not empower you—it invalidates you. It feels like a demand to suppress your emotions and pretend everything is fine. That does not motivate healing. It delays it.

Encouragement becomes toxic when it ignores your current state and imposes a timeline or emotional standard. What sounds motivational to one person can feel like rejection to someone who is hurting. If you are healing from trauma, you do not need cheerleading. You need acknowledgment. You need someone who understands that healing is not a performance. It is a process, and it begins with truth.

Please Rate This Article

Please Leave Us Your Comment
Also, tell us of any topics we might have missed.

Thank you for your comment. You may receive an email to follow up. We never share your data with marketers.

-/ 30 /-

What do you think about this?
Please share your thoughts in a comment above!