The Mind-Brain Bias And How This Deters People From Getting Help When They Need It

The Challenge of Helping Scam Victims When They Cannot Accept What Has Happened to Their Brain from Trauma

Primary Category: Scam Victim Recovery Psychology

Authors:
•  Vianey Gonzalez B.Sc(Psych) – Licensed Psychologist Specialty in Crime Victim Trauma Therapy, Neuropsychologist, Certified Deception Professional, Psychology Advisory Panel & Director of the Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.
•  Tim McGuinness, Ph.D. – Anthropologist, Scientist, Director of the Society of Citizens Against Relationship Scams Inc.

About This Article

The mind-brain bias, a cognitive bias rooted in the belief that the mind and self are distinct from brain processes, significantly hinders individuals, including scam victims, from seeking essential psychological, psychiatric, or neurological help after experiencing trauma.

This bias, influenced by dualistic thinking and cultural beliefs, leads to a misunderstanding of mental health, where individuals may reject the idea that their symptoms are brain-based and instead attribute them to personal weakness or spiritual issues. As a result, victims might avoid evidence-based treatments, such as psychiatric medication or therapy, out of fear of judgment or being labeled “crazy.”

This reluctance to seek help can delay recovery, exacerbate symptoms, and lead to social isolation, ultimately making the healing process more challenging. Addressing this bias is crucial for improving mental health outcomes and encouraging timely, effective intervention for those in need.

The Mind-Brain Bias – How it Prevents Scam Victims from Getting the Help They Need!

Mind-Brain Bias is often referred to as a cognitive bias or philosophical bias regarding the mind-body problem or perspective.

The Mind-Brain Bias involves the reluctance or difficulty in accepting that our sense of “self” and consciousness—what we perceive as “we”—is fundamentally the result of physical processes in the brain. This bias is rooted in the deep-seated dualism that many people hold, where the mind and body (or brain) are seen as distinct entities.

Mind-Body Key Concepts

Mind-Body Dualism:

The idea of dualism, historically associated with philosophers like René Descartes, posits that the mind and body are separate. The mind is often viewed as a non-physical entity, while the body, including the brain, is physical. This belief is widespread and can lead to resistance against fully accepting that consciousness, emotions, and the “self” are entirely products of brain processes.

Essentialism:

Psychological Essentialism is the belief that certain categories, including the self, have an underlying essence that makes them what they are. People may intuitively think that their “self” or soul exists independently of their physical brain, which can lead to a bias against accepting purely physical explanations for consciousness.

Cognitive Biases:

Naive Dualism: A cognitive bias where people tend to think of the mind and body as separate. This bias can manifest in the way individuals reject the idea that the brain’s physical processes wholly account for their mental experiences.

Introspection Illusion: This bias occurs when people believe they have direct insight into the workings of their own minds, often leading them to overestimate the accuracy or importance of introspective self-knowledge compared to scientific understanding of brain processes.

The Hard Problem of Consciousness:

Coined by philosopher David Chalmers, this refers to the difficulty of explaining why and how physical processes in the brain give rise to subjective experiences—what it feels like to be “you.” Many people find it hard to reconcile their subjective experience of being a “self” with the scientific explanation that this experience is a product of neural activity.

Why This Mind-Brain Bias Exists

Evolutionary Psychology: From an evolutionary perspective, humans evolved to be highly social creatures, and our perception of self and others as distinct entities is central to social interaction. This contributes to a natural tendency to resist the idea that the self is just a product of brain activity – in other words, that the self is just ‘meat’.

Cultural and Religious Beliefs: Many cultures and religions promote the idea of a soul or spirit, something beyond and separate from the physical body. This deeply ingrained belief system makes it challenging for individuals to accept that the “self” is purely the result of biological processes, especially when it is injured or in need of help.

Subjective Experience: The subjective nature of consciousness is so compelling and immediate that it can be difficult for individuals to conceptualize it as the product of impersonal physical processes in our brains. The immediacy and richness of personal experience often feel at odds with the idea of the brain as a biological machine.

Mind-Brain Bias and Scam Victims

The mind-brain bias, which involves the reluctance or difficulty in accepting that our mental experiences and sense of self are products of brain processes, can significantly hinder individuals, including scam victims, from seeking the psychological, psychiatric, or neurological help they need after experiencing significant trauma. This bias manifests in several ways that can delay or prevent effective treatment:

Stigma and Misunderstanding of Mental Health

Mind-Body Dualism: Many individuals influenced by dualistic thinking might believe that mental health issues are separate from physical health and should be addressed through non-medical means. This can lead to a preference for solutions that focus on willpower, spirituality, or moral support rather than seeking professional psychological or psychiatric help, which they see as unnecessary or inappropriate.

Cultural Beliefs: In cultures where there is a strong belief in the separation of mind and body, mental health issues might be viewed as a failure of character or spirit rather than as a medical issue that requires professional intervention. This can deter individuals from seeking help due to fear of being stigmatized or misunderstood.

Fear of Judgment and Stigma: The fear of being judged or labeled as “crazy” by others can be a powerful deterrent. This fear is rooted in the stigma surrounding mental health, where admitting to psychological struggles is often perceived as a sign of weakness or instability. Scam victims, who are already dealing with feelings of shame and guilt, are especially sensitive to this kind of judgment.

Denial and Resistance to Treatment

Refusal to Acknowledge Trauma as Brain-Based: When individuals fail to recognize that trauma has neurological and psychological effects, they may downplay the severity of their symptoms. For example, a scam victim might believe that their feelings of anxiety, depression, or PTSD are simply a result of weak character rather than recognizing these as symptoms of trauma that have a physiological basis in the brain.

Preference for Non-Medical Solutions: This bias can also lead to a preference for non-medical solutions, such as self-help, ignoring the problem, or relying solely on community support. While these can be important aspects of recovery, they are often not sufficient for addressing the complex neurological and psychological impacts of trauma, such as those experienced by scam victims.

Underutilization of Evidence-Based Treatments

Skepticism Towards Psychiatric Medication: The mind-brain bias may lead individuals to reject the idea of using medication to treat conditions like depression, anxiety, or PTSD. They might view psychiatric medication as treating the brain but not the “real” issue, which they perceive to be more spiritual or moral in nature. This can prevent them from benefiting from medications that could help stabilize their mood, reduce anxiety, or manage other symptoms.

Reluctance to Engage in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): Since CBT and other forms of therapy work on the premise that changing thought patterns can alter brain function and behavior, individuals with a strong mind-brain bias might resist these treatments. They might not believe that “just talking” or “thinking differently” can have a real impact on their condition, even though such therapies are well-supported by evidence.

Delayed Recovery

Chronic Stress and Its Effects: The longer someone with trauma delays seeking help due to mind-brain bias, the more likely they are to experience chronic stress. Chronic stress can have significant neurological impacts, such as shrinking the hippocampus (which is involved in memory) and increasing the size of the amygdala (which is involved in fear and anxiety). This can make symptoms worse over time, leading to a more difficult recovery process.

Compounded Trauma: Without proper intervention, the psychological effects of the initial trauma (such as being scammed) can be compounded by the stress of ongoing mental health issues. This can lead to a cycle of worsening symptoms and increased difficulty in eventually seeking and benefiting from treatment.

Impact on Relationships and Social Support

Isolation: Individuals who do not seek help because of the mind-brain bias may become isolated from their social support networks. Friends and family might not understand their refusal to seek treatment and may pull away, further exacerbating feelings of loneliness and distress.

Miscommunication: The bias can lead to miscommunication with healthcare providers. If a person does not fully acknowledge the brain-based nature of their symptoms, they might not communicate effectively about their experiences, leading to less effective treatment.

Summary

While not typically referred to as a “Mind-Brain Bias,” the reluctance to accept that the mind and self are purely the results of brain processes can be considered a cognitive bias influenced by dualistic thinking, introspection illusion, and essentialist beliefs. This bias highlights the complex interplay between our intuitions, cultural influences, and scientific understanding of the brain. Recognizing this bias is important for advancing discussions in philosophy, neuroscience, and psychology.

The mind-brain bias can significantly deter individuals, including scam victims, from seeking necessary psychological, psychiatric, or neurological help. This bias leads to misunderstandings about the nature of mental health, resistance to effective treatments, and delays in recovery, ultimately exacerbating the impacts of trauma. Recognizing and addressing this bias is crucial for encouraging individuals to seek appropriate care and for improving mental health outcomes.

Please Rate This Article

Please Leave Us Your Comment
Also, tell us of any topics we might have missed.

Thank you for your comment. You may receive an email to follow up. We never share your data with marketers.

Recent ScamsNOW Reader Comments

See Comments for this Article at the Bottom of the Page

• on A Reflection on Christ’s Suffering and Radical Acceptance of the Worst Possible Outcome – 2025: “A strong message, especially at this time of Easter!” Apr 19, 23:16
• on A Small Drop Of Insight About Victims’ Trauma: “This lesson was very impactful for me. I have experiences these short-circuit flashbacks and it does bring back the trauma.…” Apr 19, 16:05
• on What is Karma – Not From an Eastern Perspective But From a Psychological Point of View – 2025: “This is so informative! It is absolutely what I see daily and it is a trap anyone can fall into…” Apr 19, 15:43
• on The Little Mermaid – A Tale of Self-Deception – A Cautionary Story for Scam Victims – 2025: “This is an appeal not only to parents, grandparents but also teachers. Let’s teach the young to distinguish good from…” Apr 19, 10:46
• on What is Karma – Not From an Eastern Perspective But From a Psychological Point of View – 2025: “This is a completely different perspective of karma, that I wasn’t familiar with. I always thought of it as: you…” Apr 18, 20:11
• on The Deception of Peter Pan – A New View of a Favorite Story – 2025: “The comparisons to what we’ve each experienced to a children’s tale that’s so familiar is a great way to explain…” Apr 18, 19:07
• on The Deception of Peter Pan – A New View of a Favorite Story – 2025: “You are right. But the more we look through the lens of criminology, the more we see the patterns.” Apr 18, 16:18
• on Are You A Serial Scam Victim? Do You Know One? – 2024: “You are doing great!” Apr 18, 16:18
• on The Deception of Peter Pan – A New View of a Favorite Story – 2025: “When you dive deep into the stories and realize how they compare to scams it’s amazing” Apr 18, 09:36
• on The Deception of Peter Pan – A New View of a Favorite Story – 2025: “Who would have thought to compare these stories , but it does open your eyes seeing how the deception compares…” Apr 18, 09:35

Important Information for New Scam Victims

Please visit www.ScamVictimsSupport.org – a SCARS Website for New Scam Victims & Sextortion Victims
SCARS Institute now offers a free recovery program at www.SCARSeducation.org
Please visit www.ScamPsychology.org – to more fully understand the psychological concepts involved in scams and scam victim recovery

If you are looking for local trauma counselors, please visit counseling.AgainstScams.org

If you need to speak with someone now, you can dial 988 or find phone numbers for crisis hotlines all around the world here: www.opencounseling.com/suicide-hotlines

A Question of Trust

At the SCARS Institute, we invite you to do your own research on the topics we speak about and publish. Our team investigates the subject being discussed, especially when it comes to understanding the scam victims-survivors’ experience. You can do Google searches, but in many cases, you will have to wade through scientific papers and studies. However, remember that biases and perspectives matter and influence the outcome. Regardless, we encourage you to explore these topics as thoroughly as you can for your own awareness.